Did Mike McDaniel just subtly question Tua Tagovailoa's athletic ceiling?

Aman Sharma

•
Did Mike McDaniel just subtly question Tua Tagovailoa's athletic ceiling? image

Ed Mulholland-Imagn Images

The Miami Dolphins appear to be standing at a turning point, and head coach Mike McDaniel may have revealed more than intended while discussing quarterback evaluation.

Speaking after a December 28 win, McDaniel described the traits he prioritizes when drafting a passer, emphasizing limitless upside, athletic versatility, and the mental ability to withstand pressure.

McDaniel quipped,
“When you draft a QB, you don’t want a ceiling… you’re taking into consideration all athletic skillsets as well if the guy’s going to be able to handle the heat.”

 

The remarks landed differently given the context. Miami had just benched Tua Tagovailoa, the quarterback tied to a four-year, $212.4 million extension with $167.1 million guaranteed.

Tagovailoa’s 2024 performance offered little insulation. Across 14 games, he totaled 2,660 passing yards, 20 touchdowns, and a career-high 15 interceptions.

His completion rate dipped to 67.7 percent, yards per attempt sat at 6.9, and his passer rating slid to 88.5 after previously reaching 101.4. Miami produced just 45 plays of 20 yards or more, ranking 31st after posting 76 such plays in 2023. 

Durability also lingered in the background. A concussion sidelined him for four games, his third diagnosed in two years, followed by a hip injury that ended his season. Since entering the league in 2020, he has averaged 12.8 starts per year.

When Miami faced stronger opponents, results followed a similar pattern. The Dolphins went 2-9 over his final 25 starts against teams with winning records. All of it framed McDaniel’s comments less as theory and more as reflection.

A rookie audition and shifting tone in Miami

With limited cap flexibility and the 2025 season winding down, Miami’s immediate future may hinge on development rather than acquisition. On Sunday, seventh-round rookie Quinn Ewers delivered a timely case for consideration.

In his second career start, he guided the Dolphins to a 20-17 victory over the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, completing 14 of 22 passes for 172 yards, two touchdowns, zero interceptions, and a 118.0 passer rating.

McDaniel praised the approach afterward, saying,

“I think Quinn played a very good game with what we asked him to do,” adding that the rookie balanced responsibility with aggression.

Miami jumped ahead early, and Ewers entered halftime with 144 passing yards, highlighted by a 63-yard touchdown to Theo Wease Jr. Protecting a double-digit lead, he attempted only seven throws in the second half.

What resonated most was composure. McDaniel highlighted Ewers’s authenticity and comfort leading a huddle, noting his intelligence and fearlessness.

Those qualities, paired with efficiency, stood in contrast to the hesitation Miami struggled with earlier in the year. Whether that contrast becomes permanent remains uncertain, but the evaluation lens in Miami appears to be shifting.

More Dolphins news:

Staff Writer