The Dallas Cowboys and Green Bay Packers delivered one of the most thrilling games of the season, finishing in a 40-40 tie at AT&T Stadium. Ties are scarce in today’s NFL, and this was the Cowboys’ first tie since November 27, 1969, against the San Francisco 49ers. The high-scoring showdown featured explosive offensive performances, dramatic momentum swings, and standout play from Dak Prescott and George Pickens—but defensive lapses prevented Dallas from claiming a win.
1. Dak Prescott’s Elite Performance
Dak Prescott was the star of the night, completing 31 of 40 passes for 319 yards and three passing touchdowns, plus a rushing touchdown for a total of four scores. He orchestrated multiple scoring drives under pressure, including a crucial touchdown late in the game. Prescott’s poise on critical downs and efficiency in the red zone reinforced why he ranks among the NFL’s top quarterbacks. Through four games, he has accumulated 1,119 passing yards, six passing touchdowns, and three interceptions, cementing his status as a potential MVP candidate and the linchpin of Dallas’ success.
2. George Pickens’ Rise
With CeeDee Lamb sidelined due to injury, George Pickens stepped up in a big way. He caught eight passes for 134 yards and two touchdowns, marking another standout performance and proving to be Prescott’s top target in Lamb’s absence. Pickens’ ability to win contested catches and stretch the field has made him a reliable weapon and a dynamic complement for Dallas’ offense. His consistent production is earning him recognition as a cornerstone of the Cowboys’ future, and long-term extension talks could be on the horizon if he keeps this form.
3. Defensive Struggles and Penalties
Despite the offensive fireworks, the Cowboys’ defense once again showed vulnerability. Dallas allowed 489 total yards, including 164 rushing yards, and surrendered 40 points to the Packers. Missed tackles, coverage breakdowns, and 11 penalties for 95 yards hampered the team’s ability to close out the game, particularly in the fourth quarter and overtime. Coordinator Brian Schottenheimer emphasized postgame that discipline and finishing plays must improve if Dallas hopes to contend deep into the playoffs.
What’s Next: Week 5 vs. New York Jets
The Cowboys (1-2-1) will travel to MetLife Stadium to face the New York Jets (0-3) on Sunday, October 5, at 12:00 PM CDT. The Jets, currently playing on Monday Night Football, are playing the Miami Dolphins, who will provide a stiff challenge. However, Dallas has the chance to rebound and build momentum. With Prescott leading the offense and Pickens continuing his breakout season, the Cowboys will aim to tighten up defensively and secure a crucial road victory to move above .500 in the standings.
The Cowboys’ first tie in more than five decades leaves them at 1-2-1. While the offense continues to impress, Prescott’s MVP-level play and Pickens’ emergence highlight just how critical it is for the defense to step up if Dallas wants to remain a serious NFC contender.