Sam Pittman replacements: Ranking Arkansas' best candidates from Rhett Lashlee to Gus Malzahn

Bill Bender

Sam Pittman replacements: Ranking Arkansas' best candidates from Rhett Lashlee to Gus Malzahn image

Arkansas coach Sam Pittman is on the hot seat of the week. 

Notre Dame routed Arkansas 56-13 in Week 5 – a blowout loss that comes one week after the Razorbacks lost 32-31 to Memphis. Arkansas (2-3) is on a three-game losing streak, and five of their last seven opponents are ranked in the AP Top 25. 

That is going to make bowl eligibility difficult for the Razorbacks. Pittman, who took over in 2020, is now 32-34. The Razorbacks also have a 14-29 record in SEC play. 

Pittman is squarely on the hot seat as a result, and there are some intriguing candidates for Arkansas if the school decides to make a move. Will Pittman be the first SEC coach fired in the 2025 college football season? We take a closer look.  

MORE; Will Arkansas fire Sam Pittman after ND loss?

What is Sam Pitman's buyout at Arkansas? 

Pittman has a unique loophole in his contract that alters his buyout based on his winning percentage since 2021. If his record is .500 or above, Arkansas owes Pittman $9.8 million. If it is below .500 – and he is at 29-27 now – then that buyout drops to $6.9 million. That is something to watch heading into the bye week. Arkansas plays at No. 15 Tennessee (Oct. 11) and at home against No. 9 Texas A&M (Oct. 18) after the bye week. 

MORE: Sam Pittman buyout, contract details

Arkansas coaching candidates to replace Sam Pittman 

Rhett Lashlee, SMU coach 

Lashlee, 42, is the most coveted choice. He was a backup quarterback at Arkansas – and he was a GA with Arkansas in 2006. Lashlee was the offensive coordinator at Auburn from 2013-16, but it's his impact as a first-time head coach at SMU that has been even more impressive. The Mustangs made the College Football Playoff in their first season in the ACC. Would Lashlee entertain this offer to move into the SEC? He is 31-14 in four seasons at SMU.

Gus Malzahn, Florida State offensive coordinator 

Malzahn, 59, would be the other logical candidate, and we've tried to make this match in the past. Malzahn played two seasons at Arkansas in 1984-85, and he gained fame as the offensive coordinator and head coach for Auburn. He led Arkansas State to a 9-3 record in 2012. Malzahn left UCF to be the offensive coordinator at Florida State. Does he have one more head coaching job left in him with the home-state pull? He's 105-62 in 13 years and led Auburn to the 2013 national title game.

Jon Sumrall, Tulane coach 

Sumrall, 43, played at Kentucky – but he has been on the SEC radar the last few coaching carousels. He is 35-10 between stops at Troy and Tulane, and he was an assistant coach at Ole Miss and Kentucky before taking his first head-coaching job. The Green Wave averaged 35.1 points per game last season and had two victories against Power 4 schools this year. 

Ryan Silverfield, Memphis coach 

The Tigers won double-digit games each of the last two seasons and are off to a 4-0 start – which included that victory against Arkansas last week. Silverfield, 45, is one of the most-proven G4 coaches, and he would be a make-sense candidate for the Razorbacks as a result. Memphis beat Florida State in 2024 and lost to Missouri by a touchdown in 2023. 

Tyson Helton, Western Kentucky coach 

Helton, 48, was an offensive coordinator at Tennessee for one season before taking the Western Kentucky job. He has led the Hilltoppers to a 51-33 record – and Western Kentucky has had a winning season in five of those six years in Conference-USA. The Hilltoppers have averaged 30-plus points in four of the last five seasons, too. Helton  has a good reputation with quarterbacks.

BENDER: Kalen DeBoer will always be close to the hot seat at Alabama

Bill Bender

Bill Bender graduated from Ohio University in 2002 and started at The Sporting News as a fantasy football writer in 2007. He has covered the College Football Playoff, NBA Finals and World Series for SN. Bender enjoys story-telling, awesomely-bad 80s movies and coaching youth sports.