Heading into championship weekend, the ACC title game is set with Duke facing Virginia. If you look only at conference play, Duke absolutely deserves to be here. The Blue Devils went 6 and 2 in ACC games, which earns them a rightful spot in the matchup. On paper, they did exactly what the conference standings require. But once you take even a single step outside ACC results, the entire picture starts to look a lot stranger.
Virginia started the season unranked, climbed as high as number 14, and now sits at number 17 heading into the championship. Duke, meanwhile, has not been ranked once all year. Several ACC teams such as Georgia Tech, Miami, SMU, and Pitt were all ranked at different points during the season and entered the final weekend with eight or more wins. Those teams look like the kind of programs that belong in a conference title game. Duke, with a 7 and 5 overall record, looks more like a mid tier bowl team than a group fighting for a championship trophy.
But conference standings do not care about any of that. Duke won six ACC games and lost only two. That alone locked them into this matchup, no matter how odd it may look from the outside.
The real problem comes when you shift to the College Football Playoff. Under the new twelve team format, five automatic bids must go to the highest ranked conference champions. The remaining seven spots go to the best teams in the rankings. The top four get first round byes, and the rest play on college campuses before advancing through the quarterfinals, semifinals, and national championship.
This is where the ACC’s situation becomes messy and potentially damaging. Think about how strange this is. Duke is 7 and 5, unranked, and still alive for the ACC Championship. Meanwhile, a team like Miami finished 10 and 2 with wins over ranked opponents and has no path at all. Duke even lost to UConn and several other unranked teams, yet they could still win the ACC and block multiple stronger ACC teams from having any chance at a national title.
That is the situation we are dealing with. And here is the wild part. It is not the committee’s fault. They do not make the rules. They just follow them. Many fans argue that the SEC gets too much favoritism, but the SEC is simply the most consistent conference and draws the most national attention. A three loss Alabama team is treated almost the same as a one loss ACC team because the SEC’s reputation carries enormous weight. Even Notre Dame benefits from name recognition, which boosts their playoff hopes regardless of the situation.
The system requires five automatic qualifiers. So if Duke pulls off the upset and wins the ACC, the conference champion would be a team that is not ranked in the top 25. That could realistically push the entire ACC out of the playoff picture. If James Madison, North Texas, or Tulane win their conference championships, they could take the final automatic spots as higher ranked champions, leaving the ACC with no teams in the playoff.
The frustrating part is that the playoff size is not the issue. If the committee simply selected the top twelve teams, the bracket would be incredible. Instead, we are looking at a world where a Duke upset might eliminate the ACC entirely, not because Duke is good enough, but because the system demands automatic bids regardless of strength.
And now the ACC may pay the price for it.
More college football news:
- Deion Sanders buyout, contract details as Colorado Buffaloes coach
- Ole Miss reportedly gives Lane Kiffin an ultimatum as family visits Florida and LSU
- Virginia Tech reportedly funding roster near top of ACC for James Franklin
- Bill Belichick goes viral for awkward handshake after Wake Forest loss
- Texas state trooper reportedly relieved of duties after player exchange at Texas A&M