No. 1 seeds to win College World Series: Wake Forest latest top seed to come up empty in Omaha

Edward Sutelan

No. 1 seeds to win College World Series: Wake Forest latest top seed to come up empty in Omaha image

The No. 1 team in the country should be that for a reason. It's the view of a committee that one team is the best in the nation, and thus the most likely to win a championship.

In just nine editions of the College Football Playoff, three of the title winners have been No. 1 seeds. In Men's March Madness history since expanding to 64 teams going back to 1985, 24 of the champions (64 percent) were No. 1 seeds — though there are four No. 1 seeds in each basketball tournament.

Baseball has not had the same type of top-tier dominance in the College World Series. The NCAA Division I Baseball Tournament has had national seeding since 1999, and during that time, rarely does the No. 1 overall seed come away with the national championship.

Wake Forest was to change that trend. The Demon Deacons were the consensus No. 1 team in the nation from mid-May onward and looked dominant in their romp to Omaha.

But to break the curse of the No. 1 seed, the Demon Deacons had to beat No. 5 LSU in the winner-take-all College World Series semifinal matchup. Win, and Wake Forest will be two wins against No. 2 Florida away from a rare win by a top national seed.

Instead, Wake Forest couldn't get the job done, failing to score in a winner-take-all Game 2 and losing on a walk-off two-run homer by Tommy White. As such, they are the latest No. 1 overall seed to fail to win the title in Omaha.

MORE: Paul Skenes vs. Rhett Lowder matchup of aces

What is the track record for No. 1 seeds, and which teams have found the most success in Omaha? Here's what you need to know.

College World Series No. 1 seed results

YearNo. 1 seedFinish
1999MiamiWon championship
2000South CarolinaSuper regional loss
2001Cal State FullertonCWS semifinal loss
2002Florida StateSuper regional loss
2003Florida StateSuper regional loss
2004TexasCWS final loss
2005TulaneCWS second round loss
2006ClemsonCWS second round loss
2007VanderbiltRegional loss
2008MiamiCWS second round loss
2009TexasCWS final loss
2010Arizona StateCWS first round loss
2011VirginiaCWS semifinal loss
2012FloridaCWS first round loss
2013North CarolinaCWS semifinal loss
2014Oregon StateRegional loss
2015UCLARegional loss
2016FloridaCWS first round loss
2017Oregon StateCWS semifinal loss
2018FloridaCWS semifinal loss
2019UCLASuper regional loss
2021ArkansasSuper regional loss
2022TennesseeSuper regional loss
2023Wake ForestCWS semifinal loss

Back in 1999, Miami entered the first NCAA tournament as the first-ever No. 1 national seed. The Hurricanes did not lose a game during the entirety of the tournament, sweeping through regionals, super regionals and the College Word Series.

Since then, No. 1 national seeds have not only gone title-less, only two have even reached the College World Series final: Texas in 2004 and again in 2009. The Longhorns lost both times, first to Cal State Fullerton and next to LSU.

There have been as many national No. 1 seeds reach the College World Series final since the seeding was installed as teams eliminated in the regionals. Vanderbilt in 2007, Oregon State in 2014 and UCLA in 2015 were each knocked out in the first round of the tournament at their home stadiums.

Wake Forest has already done enough this year to snap a run of three straight tournaments that featured top teams losing in the super regionals. But the Demon Deacons' loss to LSU marks the 12th straight year that the national championship did not feature the pre-tournament top team in the country.

MORE: College World Series bracket, schedule

CWS wins by national seed

SeedChampionships
11
23
33
41
52
60
71
80
Unranked12

To date, a majority of the 23 national championships since 1999 have come from unranked teams. That will change in 2023, when one of No. 1 Wake Forest, No. 2 Florida or No. 5 LSU wins the title, which will officially even up the tally at 12 ranked and 12 unranked.

Of the 12 unranked, six were regional hosts. In 2018, the NCAA tournament officially expanded to 16 national seeds instead of the previous eight, which would have meant those six would have counted toward the nationally ranked.

The most common nationally ranked teams to win a title are No. 2 and 3 seeds, with the two each coming away with three titles each. Florida would give No. 2 seeds the most titles with four, while LSU would give No. 5 seeds a tie with three. 

Edward Sutelan

Edward Sutelan joined The Sporting News in 2021 after covering high school sports for PennLive. Edward graduated from The Ohio State University in 2019, where he gained experience covering the baseball, football and basketball teams. Edward also spent time working for The Columbus Dispatch and Cape Cod Times.