Biggest contracts in sports history: Where Aaron Judge and Carlos Correa's new salaries rank among MLB, other stars

Edward Sutelan

Biggest contracts in sports history: Where Aaron Judge and Carlos Correa's new salaries rank among MLB, other stars image

The Yankees have lost out on many major free agency bidding wars in recent years. They weren't going to be outdone on their homegrown star.

Aaron Judge agreed to a massive nine-year, $360 million deal to remain in pinstripes after an MVP-winning season in which he launched 62 home runs with a slash line of .311/.425/.686.

Judge's contract with the Yankees immediately places him in the upper echelon of the highest paid athletes in the world, and the figures above the dotted line make the deal one of the richest both by total value and in average annual value.

Where does Judge's new deal rank all-time among athlete contracts? Here's a look:

MORE: MLB winter meetings tracker

Biggest contracts by total value

This is where Judge gets closest to the top.

The $360 million set to go Judge's way is the largest contract signed by an MLB free agent in history. It exceeds Bryce Harper's 13-year, $330 million deal signed to the Phillies in 2019 and an identical deal signed by Carlos Correa to the Giants ahead of the 2023 MLB season. In MLB, only Mike Trout's 12-year, $426.5 million Angels deal and Mookie Betts' 12-year, $365 million contract with the Dodgers will pay the players more.

Among all athletes, only six total have signed more lucrative deals than Judge. The list is topped by Lionel Messi, who signed a four-year, $674 million contract with FC Barcelona in 2017. Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes has the North American sports record with his 10-year, $503 million contract that he inked in 2020.

MORE: 15 worst MLB free-agent signings of all time

Likely soon to be adding to the list will be Cristiano Ronaldo, who is expected to sign a 2.5-year deal with Al Nassr that will pay him $525 million in total value.

Of the 11 highest-valued contracts in sports, eight have been signed by Major League Baseball players and teams.

AthleteTeamYearsValue
Lionel MessiFC Barcelona4$674 million
Patrick MahomesChiefs10$503 million
Mike TroutAngels12$426.5 million
Canelo ÁlvarezDAZN5$365 million
Mookie BettsDodgers12$365 million
Aaron JudgeYankees9$360 million
Francisco LindorMets10$341 million
Fernando Tatís Jr.Padres14$340 million
Rafael DeversRed Sox11$331 million
Bryce HarperPhillies13$330 million
Giancarlo StantonMarlins13$325 million
Corey SeagerRangers10$325 million

And there are plenty more MLB stars that have signed huge contracts. Just this offseason, Judge, Devers, Correa (Mets) and Trea Turner (Phillies) have agreed to four of the 12 most lucrative contracts in MLB history.

Of the 11 highest-paying contracts in MLB history, the Padres, Phillies and Yankees each have signed players to two of the highest-paying deals. The Yankees also took on the massive contract Giancarlo Stanton originally signed with the Marlins.

Here's a look at the highest-paying deals in MLB history.

PlayerTeamYearsValue
Mike TroutAngels12$426.5 million
Mookie BettsDodgers12$365 million
Aaron JudgeYankees9$360 million
Francisco LindorMets10$341 million
Fernando Tatis Jr.Padres14$340 million
Rafael DeversRed Sox11$331 million
Bryce HarperPhillies13$330 million
Giancarlo StantonMarlins13$325 million
Corey SeagerRangers10$325 million
Gerrit ColeYankees9$324 million
Carlos CorreaMets12$315 million
Manny MachadoPadres10$300 million
Trea TurnerPhillies10$300 million

But plenty of those deals were signed as extensions rather than open-market contracts. Part of what makes Judge's contract historic is that he inked his deal as a free agent rather than while he was still with the team.

No contract signed in free agency has been larger than Judge's to this point.

PlayerTeamFA YearContract YearsValue
Aaron JudgeYankees20239$360 million
Carlos CorreaGiants202313$330 million
Bryce HarperPhillies201913$330 million
Corey SeagerRangers202210$325 million
Gerrit ColeYankees20209$324 million
Manny MachadoPadres201910$300 million
Trea TurnerPhillies202311$300 million
Alex RodriguezYankees200810$275 million
Alex RodriguezRangers200110$252 million
Anthony RendonAngels20207$245 million
Albert PujolsAngels201210$240 million
Robinson CanoMariners201410$240 million

Biggest contracts by average annual value

When it comes to average annual value, Judge still trails a number of athletes, though he does still come away with at least one record.

Judge's $40 million per season will be the highest ever for a position player in baseball. However, pitchers have recently begun to run away with the distinction for highest average annual value in the sport. Earlier this offseason, Justin Verlander signed a two-year, $86.6 million deal with the Mets, which is tied with now-Mets teammate Max Scherzer ($43.3 million).

Ronaldo's upcoming deal with Al Nassr would set the record for highest average annual value by a comfortable margin, with his deal set to pay him $210 million per year.

MORE: Jon Heyman sets off 'Arson Judge' firestorm with premature Judge to Giants report

But before that deal is done, here's a look at the highest paid athletes in sports history.

AthleteTeamYearsAAV
Lionel MessiFC Barcelona4$168.5 million
Canelo ÁlvarezDAZN5$73 million
Devin BookerSuns4$56.056 million
Karl-Anthony TownsTimberwolves4$56.056 million
Nikola JokićNuggets5$54.404 million
Stephen CurryWarriors4$53.838 million
Max VerstappenRed Bull Racing5$53.3 million
Joel Embiid76ers4$52.528 million
Kimi RäikkönenFerrari3$51 million
Bradley BealWizards5$50.204 million

The NBA has the largest group of athletes ranked by average annual value, but MLB players aren't too far behind, particularly with some of the recent contracts signed by pitchers.

And while Judge doesn't quite top the list, he does come close behind two other New York players.

PlayerTeamYearsAAV
Max ScherzerMets3$43.33 million
Justin VerlanderMets2$43.33 million
Aaron JudgeYankees9$40 million
Jacob deGromRangers5$37 million
Gerrit ColeYankees9$36 million
Mike TroutAngels12$35.542 million
Stephen StrasburgNationals7$35 million
Anthony RendonAngels7$35 million
Zack GreinkeDiamondbacks6$34.417 million

Sporting News' Jacob Camenker also contributed to this report.

Edward Sutelan

Edward Sutelan joined The Sporting News in 2021 after covering high school sports for PennLive. Edward graduated from The Ohio State University in 2019, where he gained experience covering the baseball, football and basketball teams. Edward also spent time working for The Columbus Dispatch and Cape Cod Times.