The Chicago Cubs may have overplayed their hand.
The result is that Japanese left-handed pitcher Shota Imanaga, who has a 3.28 ERA through his first two seasons with the Cubs, is now a surprise free agent.
ESPN's Jesse Rogers broke the news on Tuesday morning, and it's a tad complicated sequence of contract dominoes.
The Cubs had originally signed Imanaga to a four-year contract, of which he's through two seasons. Built into the contract was an option for Chicago, after the second season, to decide to tack a fifth year onto the end of the deal.
The Cubs, according to Rogers, chose to reject that chance at a fifth year.
That aspect of the contract was tied to another: If the Cubs rejected a fifth year, the 2026 season became a $15 million player option campaign for Imanaga, rather than a standard contract year. And he declined the newly created player option.
If the Cubs had added the fifth year onto Imanaga's contract, he wouldn't have had a route to free agency right now. But in their rejection of it, they opened the door, and Imanaga walked out.
MORE: Mets named best free agent fit for Yankees' 30-year-old star
So Imanaga is a free agent, rather than being under Cubs control for either the next two or three seasons.
He put up a 2.91 ERA with a 15-3 record in 2024. In 2025, Imanaga had a 9-8 mark with a 3.73 ERA and 117 strikeouts in 144.2 innings pitched.
He may not be overpowering, but he's clearly a valuable member of a starting rotation. Now, if the Cubs want to keep him around, they'll have to negotiate a new contract with him.
And the rest of MLB, which surely wasn't planning on Imanaga hitting the open market, can start putting their hats into the ring, too.
MLB rumors update
- Dodgers, Giants predicted to battle for $400 million free agent superstar
- White Sox make $20 million Luis Robert Jr. Contract decision after trade rumors
- Eugenio Suarez is looking at 5 possible landing spots
- Pete Alonso seems likely to stay in the NL East