The college football season reaches its crescendo with a compelling New Year's Eve triple-header that offers bettors a final opportunity to capitalize on the 2024 campaign. This slate features three intriguing neutral-site matchups, with the first contest kicking off at 12:00 PM ET and the final showdown beginning at 3:30 PM ET.
College Football Picks: Best Bets for New Year's Eve
Each game presents clear favorites backed by explosive offensive units, as Utah, Vanderbilt, and Duke bring high-powered attacks to their respective bowl destinations. The underdogs—Nebraska, Iowa, and Arizona State—face the challenge of keeping pace with these scoring juggernauts in what promises to be an entertaining conclusion to the season.
These neutral-site affairs create fascinating betting dynamics, with spread differentials ranging from a modest field goal to a hefty two-touchdown margin. The betting markets are showing decisive action toward the favorites, but savvy handicappers know that bowl season often produces unexpected results when teams have extended preparation time and unique motivation factors come into play.
New users can sign up with the BetMGM bonus code to win $150 in bonus bets or claim a $1,500 First Bet Offer, depending on their location.
Week 19 CFB Spreads & Totals
The betting landscape for this New Year's Eve slate showcases clear market sentiment, with two contests featuring meaningful spreads and one reaching double digits:
- Iowa Hawkeyes @ Vanderbilt Commodores: Spread: Vanderbilt -4.5, Total: 45.5
- Arizona State Sun Devils @ Duke Blue Devils: Spread: Duke -3.5, Total: 47.5
- Nebraska Cornhuskers @ Utah Utes: Spread: Utah -14.5, Total: 50.5
All betting lines are from consensus odds.
Notable line movement has occurred in the Nebraska-Utah contest, where the spread opened at Utah -13.5 before climbing to its current -14.5. This one-point bump reflects heavy action on the Utes from both public and sharp bettors who view Nebraska's ground-and-pound attack as ill-equipped to match Utah's air raid efficiency. The Iowa-Vanderbilt total has also seen notable movement, dropping from an opening number of 46.5 to 45.5 as early money favored the Under.
NCAAF Week 19 Predictions: Top ATS & Over/Under Picks
Here are our fearless forecasts against the spread (ATS) and total predictions for the complete New Year's Eve college football slate:
| Matchup | ATS Pick | O/U Pick |
|---|---|---|
| Iowa @ Vanderbilt | Vanderbilt -4.5 | Under 45.5 |
| Arizona State @ Duke | Duke -3.5 | Under 47.5 |
| Nebraska @ Utah | Utah -14.5 | Over 50.5 |
Vanderbilt -4.5 vs. Iowa
The Commodores possess a decisive offensive advantage that should translate into comfortable spread coverage. Vanderbilt's explosive attack generates 39.2 points per game, a substantial 10.6-point edge over Iowa's pedestrian 28.6 PPG output. This disparity becomes even more pronounced when examining third-down efficiency, where Vanderbilt converts at an elite 53.2% clip compared to Iowa's modest 43.0% success rate.
While Vanderbilt's offense should control the tempo, the total appears inflated given Iowa's limitations. The Hawkeyes manage just 315.2 yards per game with their conservative approach, and their inability to sustain drives will likely cap the game's scoring potential. Iowa does boast exceptional red zone efficiency at 93.5%, but reaching the red zone consistently against Vanderbilt's defense presents the primary challenge.
Narrative -> Pick: Vanderbilt's third-down prowess and scoring differential create the blueprint for a methodical cover in a lower-scoring affair.
- ATS Pick: Vanderbilt -4.5
- O/U Pick: Under 45.5
Duke -3.5 vs. Arizona State
This matchup hinges on ball security and offensive consistency, two categories where the Blue Devils maintain commanding advantages. Duke's remarkable +9 turnover differential stands in stark contrast to Arizona State's problematic -3 mark, creating a 12-turnover gap that typically proves decisive in close contests. The Blue Devils also demonstrate superior offensive reliability, averaging 33.4 points per game to ASU's 24.2 while converting third downs at a 39.4% rate compared to the Sun Devils' 33.3%.
Despite Duke's statistical superiority, a defensive struggle appears likely. Arizona State's offense has managed just 24.2 points per game while surrendering 17 turnovers, limiting their ability to engage in a high-scoring affair. The Sun Devils do generate consistent pass rush with 32.0 sacks, which could prevent Duke from completely dominating the scoreboard.
New users can get the DraftKings promo code to win a $200 college football bonus.
Narrative -> Pick: Duke's ball security and offensive efficiency will grind out a cover in a defensive-minded bowl game.
- ATS Pick: Duke -3.5
- O/U Pick: Under 47.5
Utah -14.5 vs. Nebraska
The Utes enter as heavy favorites behind one of the nation's most explosive offensive units, and the Allegiant Stadium dome provides perfect conditions for their aerial attack to flourish. Utah's juggernaut offense produces 40.8 points and 478.6 yards per game while converting an astounding 52.8% of third-down attempts and scoring on 90.4% of red zone possessions. Nebraska's respectable 29.1 points per game simply cannot match this blistering pace.
The climate-controlled environment favors an offensive showcase that should easily surpass the 50.5-point total. Utah possesses the firepower to reach 40+ points independently, requiring Nebraska to contribute just modest scoring to push the total Over. The Cornhuskers demonstrate enough offensive competency with their 45.2% third-down conversion rate and positive turnover differential (+1) to find the end zone multiple times against a Utah defense that has shown recent vulnerabilities.
Narrative -> Pick: Utah's air raid offense will dominate in perfect dome conditions while Nebraska contributes enough scoring for a high-total game.
- ATS Pick: Utah -14.5
- O/U Pick: Over 50.5
Week 19 Weather: Dome Provides Perfect Conditions for Primetime Showdown
Weather conditions will play a minimal role across the New Year's Eve slate, with one contest completely eliminating the elements as a factor:
- Nebraska Cornhuskers @ Utah Utes: This matchup takes place inside the climate-controlled Allegiant Stadium in Las Vegas, where perfect conditions on artificial turf will showcase both teams' offensive capabilities without weather interference.
- Iowa Hawkeyes @ Vanderbilt Commodores: The outdoor setting at Raymond James Stadium in Tampa, Florida, requires monitoring as Florida weather patterns can shift rapidly during bowl season.
- Arizona State Sun Devils @ Duke Blue Devils: El Paso's Sun Bowl requires tracking for any wind factors that could impact the passing game, as weather information is not available.