NFL trade deadline winners & losers: Colts, Eagles, Seahawks go all in; Jets fold and flop

Vinnie Iyer

NFL trade deadline winners & losers: Colts, Eagles, Seahawks go all in; Jets fold and flop image

There were 22 players who changed teams before Tuesday's NFL trade deadline when accounting for all the moves made from Oct. 1 to Nov. 4.

That means a lot of teams either upgraded for now, stockpiled for later, or on the flip side, decided to stand pat.

Here's breaking down who all should feel good or bad about the moves, from teams to players:

MORE NFL TRADE DEADLINE:

NFL trade deadline 2025 winners & losers

Sauce Gardner

Winners: Indianapolis Colts

Sauce Gardner isn't Alontae Taylor, Riq Woolen or other cornerback who was on the trade market before the deadline. He's an absolute superstar shutdown cover man in the right system and the kind of move that turns a good all-around Colts team into a true AFC title contender to live up to its current No. 1 seed.

MORE: How Colts aced Sauce Gardner deal with Jets

Winners: Seattle Seahawks

The Seahawks did the move everyone expected with acquiring wide receiver Rashid Shaheed and the play of Sam Darnold throwing downfield in Washington on Monday night confirmed it was the right play to make their aggressive even more dangerous with Jaxon Smith-Njigba. Shaheed also doesn't need any time to learn the Klint Kubiak offense he knows from last year in New Orleans.

MORE: How Rashid Shaheed fits into Seahawks offense

Losers: New York Jets

The Jets moved Sauce Gardner, Michael Carter II and Quinnen Williams, who were indispensable defensive pieces just a few years ago. This fire sale isn't inspiring to either fans or players.

MORE: Ranking Jets best QB options in 2026, 2027 NFL Drafts

Winners: Philadelphia Eagles

The Eagles needed key reinforcements for their pass defense and got them with Carter, Jaire Alexander and the real important piece, edge pass rusher Jaelan Phillips.

Winner: Quinnen Williams

The Cowboys were so-so with getting Logan Wilson but made up for it with Williams big time. Williams will be a difference-making versatile power for them for years to come.

MORE: How Quinnen Williams, Logan Wilson beef up Cowboys defense

Loser: Breece Hall

Hall saw many of his friends leave town and find good non-Jets homes. Hall didn't land with any contenders, from the Chiefs to the Chargers to the Steelers to the Patriots. He gets stuck on a free-falling team with a bad offense.

MORE: Why Jets opted not to trade Breece Hall at deadline

Winners: Baltimore Ravens

The Ravens did well to shore up some defensive spots with Dre'Mont Jones and Alohi Gilman without giving up too much.

Winners: Cincinnati Bengals

Surprisingly, they did OK despite not moving Trey Hendrickson, getting something for Logan Wilson and also finding their ideal Joe Burrow backup, Joe Flacco. It's not Flacco's fault the defense stinks with Hendrickson.

Loser: Trey Hendrickson

Hendrickson has wanted out of Cincinnati for a long time but didn't get his wish. So he needs to keep playing out in a shaky defensive scheme.

Joseph Maiorana-Imagn Images

Winners: Los Angeles Chargers

The Chargers didn't do too much but Odafe Oweh and Trevor Penning help nicely with some injury issues.

Losers: Rest of AFC West

The Raiders gave up and got rid of Jakobi Meyers instead of keeping him. The Chiefs didn't feel like they needed an impact move. The Broncos teased for big moves but came up empty in trying to bolster their status ahead of the Chargers and Chiefs.

MORE: What Jakobi Meyers trade to Jaguars means for Travis Hunter's injury

Winners: Buffalo Bills

The Bills didn't waste time making a forced move for a wide receiver or another position when the ideal acquisition wasn't there because Williams couldn't be traded from the Jets inside the division.

Losers: Miami Dolphins

The Dolphins did move Phillips but sat on Bradley Chubb, Jaylen Waddle and others despite having a lot of buzz after firing GM Chris Grier. That wasn't good for their rebuilding process.

Senior Writer

Editorial Team