NFL suspensions under Roger Goodell: Reviewing off-the-field bans in wake of Deshaun Watson's suspension

Jacob Camenker

NFL suspensions under Roger Goodell: Reviewing off-the-field bans in wake of Deshaun Watson's suspension image

Roger Goodell had an important goal in mind in the early stages of his time as the NFL's commissioner. He wanted to establish himself as a disciplinarian who created consequences for players that committed on- and off-the-field transgressions.

Goodell was able to accomplish that mission. He took office in September of 2006 and quickly got to work revising some key policies across the NFL. Notably, he introduced a beefed-up personal conduct policy to the league in April of 2007, and that policy allowed the NFL to take more control over player discipline than ever.

The policy has been far from perfect. It contains within it plenty of vagaries and gray areas that haven't been addressed even in the 15 years since Goodell rolled it out. This has created some muddled precedents that make it difficult to predict exactly how long suspensions will be.

IYER: Why NFL's Deshaun Watson, Calvin Ridley suspensions can't be compared

We saw that firsthand with the Deshaun Watson case. While the NFL pushed for a full, year-long suspension after 24 women accused him of sexual assault and misconduct, Watson's representatives argued that Watson hadn't done anything wrong and thus deserved no suspension.

That put arbiter Sue L. Robinson in a tough spot, but ultimately, she chose to trust the personal conduct policy that the NFL has in writing to inform her punishment. As such, Watson will be suspended for the first six games of the 2022 NFL season, barring an appeal from the NFL.

Watson's suspension has drawn a lot of attention, as it is shorter than some other recent suspensions under the personal conduct policy, the NFL's substances of abuse policy and the suspension the league gave to Calvin Ridley for gambling.

How does Watson's suspension compare to other suspensions levied by Goodell and the NFL? Here's a look back at some of the longest suspensions during Goodell's 15-plus year tenure.

MORE: Sue L. Robinson explains why she suspended Deshaun Watson six games

NFL personal conduct policy suspensions under Roger Goodell

Below is a list of the notable suspensions that Goodell has levied for personal conduct policy violations during his time as the NFL's commissioner. Included are all suspensions of at least four games for off-the-field transgressions as well as some other suspensions that contain within them "aggravating factors" that impacted the length of Watson's suspension.

DatePlayerLengthViolation
Nov. 22, 2006Ricky Manning1 gameDomestic violence
May 15, 2007Chris Henry8 gamesPersonal conduct policy
May 15, 2007Adam JonesEntire 2007 seasonAttacking a stripper and threatening a security guard's life
June 4, 2007Tank Johnson8 gamesFirearms charge, violation of probation
July 27, 2007Michael VickIndefinite (2 years)Dog fighting scandal
July 14, 2008Darrion Scott3 gamesChild endangerment
August 30, 2008Bryant McKinnie4 gamesAggravated battery arrest
Oct. 14, 2008Adam Jones4 gamesAltercation with a bodyguard
Dec. 8, 2008Plaxico Burress4 gamesAccidental shooting with a firearm
Aug. 13, 2009Donté StallworthEntire 2009 seasonKilled a pedestrian while DUI
Sept. 23, 2009Plaxico BurressUntil release from prisonAccidental shooting with a firearm
April 21, 2010Ben Roethlisberger6 games (reduced to 4)Rape charges
August 18, 2011Terrelle Pryor5 gamesImproper benefits scandal at Ohio State
Oct. 25, 2011Chris CookEntire 2011 seasonDomestic assault charges
May 2, 2012Jonathan VilmaEntire 2012 season (later overturned)Bountygate scandal
May 2, 2012Anthony Hargrove8 games (later overturned)Bountygate scandal
May 2, 2012Will Smith4 games (later overturned)Bountygate scandal
May 2, 2012Scott Fujita3 games (later overturned)Bountygate scandal
Nov. 4, 2013Richie IncognitoIndefiniteDolphins bullying scandal
Sept. 2, 2014Josh Brent10 gamesManslaughter conviction
Sept. 2, 2014Ray RiceIndefinite (overturned after two months)Domestic violence
Nov. 18, 2014Adrian PetersonIndefiniteChild abuse charges
April 22, 2015Greg Hardy10 games (reduced to 4)Domestic abuse charge
May 11, 2015Tom Brady4 gamesDeflategate scandal
Sept. 8, 2015Brandon Spikes4 gamesUndisclosed
Sept. 8, 2015Mike Williams6 gamesUndisclosed
Sept. 8, 2015Jonathan Dwyer3 gamesDomestic violence
Sept. 8, 2015Jermaine Cunningham6 gamesPersonal conduct policy
Sept. 8, 2015Rodney Austin6 gamesGuilty domestic violence charge
Sept. 11, 2015IK Enemkpali4 gamesPunching and injuring teammate Geno Smith
Oct. 19, 2015Quincy Enunwa4 gamesDomestic violence charge
Nov. 10, 2015Joseph Randle4 gamesDomestic violence with a weapon
Oct. 14, 2016Derrick Coleman4 gamesGuilty domestic violence charge
Aug. 11, 2017Ezekiel Elliott6 gamesInvolvement in domestic violence case
Sept. 8, 2017Josh Brown6 gamesDomestic violence
June 15, 2018Roy Miller6 gamesBattery arrest
June 28, 2018Jameis Winston3 gamesSexual harassment accusation
Aug. 21, 2018Jimmy Smith4 gamesEmotionally abusive behaviors
Oct. 2, 2018Mychal Kendricks8 gamesGuilty plea to insider trading
July 31, 2020Antonio Brown8 gamesConduct detrimental to the league
Nov. 13, 2020Mark Walton8 gamesAggravated battery charge
Aug. 13, 2021Derrius Guice6 gamesThree domestic violence incidences
Sept. 15, 2021D.J. Fluker6 gamesUndisclosed
Aug. 1, 2022Deshaun Watson6 games24 accusations of sexual assault and misconduct

DeCOURCY: Why Sue L. Robinson fumbled decision in Deshaun Watson case

NFL substance abuse suspensions under Roger Goodell

Goodell has been somewhat harsh about players violating the NFL's personal conduct policy, but he has brought the hammer down harder on those that violate the NFL's PED and substance abuse policies.

Since becoming commissioner, Goodell has suspended 360 players for violating those league policies. Below is a list of all the four-plus game suspensions that Goodell has amassed over the years.

DatePlayerLength
Sept. 1, 2006Sammy Morris4 games
Sept. 25, 2006Odell Thurman

Entire 2006 and 2007 seasons

Oct. 17, 2006Matt Lehr4 games
Oct. 17, 2006Shaun Rogers4 games
Oct. 17, 2006Koren Robinson

Entire 2006 season

Oct. 22, 2006Shawne Merriman4 games
Dec. 5, 2006Hollis Thomas4 games
July 4, 2007Dominic Rhodes4 games
July 6, 2007Kenny Peterson4 games
July 20, 2007Jarrod Cooper4 games
Aug. 3, 2007Ryan Tucker4 games
Aug. 9, 2007Obafemi Ayanbadejo4 games
Sept. 2, 2007Rodney Harrison4 games
Oct. 5, 2007Tim Couch6 games
Oct. 5, 2007Kenard Lang6 games
Nov. 3, 2007Chris Henry4 games
Nov. 6, 2007Marcus Stroud4 games
Dec. 5, 2007Ray Edwards4 games
April 15, 2008Stephen Cooper4 games
June 6, 2008Odell ThurmanIndefinite
June 12, 2008Adrian Awasom4 games
Aug. 19, 2008Luke Petitgout4 games
Aug. 30, 2008Jesse Chatman4 games
Aug. 31, 2008Jonathan Clinkscale4 games
Aug. 31, 2008Tony Gonzalez4 games
Aug. 31, 2008Mario Haggan4 games
Aug. 31, 2008Luke Petitgout4 games
Aug. 31, 2008Dexter Reid4 games
Aug. 31, 2008E. J. Underwood4 games
Aug. 31, 2008Jimmy Williams5 games
Aug. 31, 2008Travis HenryIndefinite
Oct. 7, 2008Darryl Blackstock4 games
July 2, 2009Calvin Pace4 games
Aug. 18, 2009Tanard Jackson4 games
Nov. 11, 2009Joselio Hanson4 games
Nov. 17, 2009Dwayne Bowe4 games
Dec. 24, 2009Luke Lawton4 games
March 7, 2010Ryan Tucker8 games
March 7, 2010Jason Ferguson8 games
April 12, 2010Santonio Holmes4 games
May 7, 2010Brian Cushing4 games
June 14, 2010Gerald McRath4 games
June 21, 2010Ed Gant4 games
July 1, 2010LenDale White4 games
July 1, 2010Hollis Thomas8 games
July 8, 2010Robert James4 games
July 16, 2010Johnny JollyIndefinite
Sept. 4, 2010Shawn Nelson4 games
Sept. 21, 2010Duane Brown4 games
Sept. 22, 2010Tanard JacksonIndefinite
Oct. 4, 2010Steve Gregory4 games
Oct. 15, 2010Antwan Odom4 games
Dec. 10, 2010Duke Robinson4 games
Dec. 10, 2010Brandon Spikes4 games
Aug. 2, 2011Phillip Buchanon4 games
Sept. 2, 2011Eric Alexander4 games
Sept. 2, 2011Eric Barton4 games
Sept. 2, 2011Robert Brewster4 games
Sept. 2, 2011Vinny Ciurciu4 games
Sept. 2, 2011Brandon Lang4 games
Sept. 2, 2011Dominic Rhodes

Entire 2011 season

Sept. 3, 2011Bobbie Williams4 games
Sept. 3, 2011Ahmard Hall4 games
Oct. 5, 2011Jaimie Thomas4 games
Oct. 12, 2011Jimmy Kennedy4 games
Dec. 4, 2011Fred Davis4 games
Dec. 4, 2011Trent Williams4 games
Dec. 6, 2011Vai Taua4 games
Dec. 6, 2011John Moffitt4 games
Dec. 21, 2011Austin Pettis4 games
Feb. 6, 2012Weslye Saunders4 games
Feb. 15, 2012Nick Miller4 games
March 9, 2012Virgil Green4 games
March 9, 2012D. J. Williams6 games
March 9, 2012Ryan McBean6 games
March 13, 2012Mike Neal4 games
March 30, 2012Andre Brown

4 games (Later overturned)[352]

May 23, 2012Allen Barbre4 games
June 13, 2012Dontay Moch4 games
July 1, 2012Trevis Turner4 games
July 2, 2012Brody Eldridge4 games
July 18, 2012Andre Neblett4 games
July 31, 2012Tyler Sash4 games
Aug. 16, 2012Garrett Brown4 games
Aug. 31, 2012Tanard JacksonIndefinite
Sept. 10, 2012Joe Haden4 games
Sept. 22, 2012Gerell Robinson4 games
Oct. 8, 2012Will Hill4 games
Oct. 13, 2012Aqib Talib4 games
Oct. 27, 2012Lee Ziemba4 games
Oct. 28, 2012Eric Wright4 games
Nov. 9, 2012Brandon Bolden4 games
Nov. 19, 2012Joe Hawley4 games
Nov. 20, 2012Winston Guy4 games
Nov. 26, 2012Jermaine Cunningham4 games
Dec. 4, 2012Cedric Griffin4 games
Dec. 5, 2012Brandon Browner4 games
Dec. 11, 2012Asa Jackson4 games
Dec. 17, 2012Jordan Black4 games
Dec. 18, 2012Quentin Saulsberry4 games
Feb. 13, 2013Javarris James4 games
March 14, 2013Deuce Lutui4 games
March 20, 2013Rob Jackson4 games
April 1, 2013Christian Thompson4 games
April 1, 2013Daryl Washington4 games
April 17, 2013Larry Grant4 games
April 19, 2013James Sanders4 games
April 20, 2013Justin Blackmon4 games
May 17, 2013Bruce Irvin4 games
June 4, 2013Gabe Miller4 games
June 24, 2013Brandon Collins4 games
June 24, 2013LaVon Brazill4 games
July 18, 2013Weslye Saunders8 games
July 19, 2013Bert Reed4 games
July 20, 2013Will Hill4 games
July 26, 2013Jarvis Jenkins4 games
July 27, 2013Andre Holmes4 games
Aug. 1, 2013DeMarcus Love4 games
Aug. 2, 2013Asa Jackson8 games
Aug. 14, 2013Jo-Lonn Dunbar4 games
Aug. 20, 2013Von Miller6 games
Aug. 26, 2013Mike Goodson4 games
Aug. 30, 2013DeQuin Evans8 games
Sept. 3, 2013R.J. Mattes4 games
Sept. 10, 2013Tom Zbikowski4 games
Oct. 12, 2013Kellen Winslow II4 games
Nov. 1, 2013Justin BlackmonIndefinite
Nov. 12, 2013LaRoy Reynolds4 games
Nov. 24, 2013Walter Thurmond4 games
Dec. 3, 2013Travis Lewis4 games
Dec. 18, 2013Brandon Browner4 games
Feb. 19, 2014Fred DavisIndefinite
April 4, 2014Jake Knott4 games
April 8, 2014Brandon Moore4 games
April 21, 2014Brian Tyms4 games
May 2, 2014Frank Alexander4 games
May 12, 2014Stedman Bailey

4 games*

May 16, 2014Robert Mathis4 games
May 30, 2014Will Hill6 games
May 30, 2014Daryl Washington

Entire 2014 season

June 4, 2014Jayron Hosley4 games
July 3, 2014Rokevious Watkins4 games
July 3, 2014Dion Jordan4 games
July 3, 2014LaVon Brazill

Entire 2014 season

July 9, 2014Tanard JacksonIndefinite
July 11, 2014Spencer Nealy4 games
July 22, 2014Ace Sanders4 games
July 23, 2014Lane Johnson4 games
Aug. 8, 2014Eric Herman4 games
Aug. 8, 2014Reshad Jones4 games
Aug. 11, 2014Orlando Scandrick

4 games*

Aug. 22, 2014Donald Stephenson4 games
Aug. 23, 2014Matt Prater4 games
Aug. 27, 2014Josh Gordon

Entire 2014 season

Aug. 29, 2014Jakar Hamilton4 games
Aug. 29, 2014Aldon Smith9 games
Sept. 2, 2014Wes Welker

4 games*

Sept. 4, 2014Erin Henderson4 games
Sept. 4, 2014Andre Brown8 games
Sept. 5, 2014D.C. Jefferson4 games
Sept. 19, 2014Dion Jordan4 games
Sept. 29, 2014LaRon Landry4 games
October 1, 2014Frank Alexander10 games
Dec. 4, 2014Haloti Ngata4 games
Dec. 17, 2014Craig Watts4 games
Feb. 3, 2015Josh Gordon

Entire 2015 season

March 7, 2015LaRon Landry10 games
April 13, 2015Victor Butler4 games
April 13, 2015Eben Britton4 games
April 28, 2015Dion Jordan

Entire 2015 season

May 29, 2015Trey Watts4 games
June 29, 2015Kyle Knox4 games
July 2, 2015Sheldon Richardson4 games
July 2, 2015Rolando McClain4 games
July 2, 2015Antonio Gates4 games
July 13, 2015Jakar Hamilton10 games
July 13, 2015Loucheiz Purifoy10 games
July 13, 2015Jarrett Bush4 games
July 24, 2015Derek Wolfe4 games
Aug. 3, 2015Ace Sanders10 games
Aug. 17, 2015Ryan Seymour4 games
Aug. 18, 2015Jerome Simpson6 games
Aug. 21, 2015Jarrett Bush10 games
Aug. 27, 2015Martavis Bryant4 games
Aug. 28, 2015R. J. Dill4 games
Oct. 2, 2015A. J. Cruz4 games
Nov. 3, 2015Kaleb Ramsey4 games
Nov. 4, 2015Trey WattsIndefinite
Nov. 9, 2015Stedman Bailey4 games
Nov. 10, 2015Tayo Fabuluje4 games
Nov. 10, 2015Jalen Saunders4 games
Nov. 12, 2015Ego Ferguson4 games
Nov. 13, 2015Clyde Gates4 games
Nov. 17, 2015Aldon Smith

Entire 2016 season

Nov. 18, 2015Silas Redd4 games
Nov. 23, 2015Wes Horton4 games
Nov. 24, 2015Frank Alexander

Entire 2015 season

Nov. 24, 2015LaRon LandryIndefinite
Dec. 7, 2015Nick Boyle4 games
Dec. 8, 2015Kwon Alexander4 games
Dec. 10, 2015Jalen Saunders10 games
Dec. 28, 2015Marcel Reece4 games
Feb. 19, 2016Nick Boyle10 games
Feb. 19, 2016Randy Gregory4 games
Feb. 19, 2016Mike Pennel4 games
March 4, 2016Armonty Bryant4 games
March 14, 2016Taylor Mays4 games
March 14, 2016Nick Moody4 games
March 14, 2016Martavis Bryant

Entire 2016 season

March 16, 2016Will Hill10 games
April 8, 2016Jalen Collins4 games
April 8, 2016Aaron Colvin4 games
April 8, 2016Demetri Goodson4 games
April 8, 2016Andrew Turzilli4 games
April 12, 2016Silas ReddIndefinite
May 6, 2016Jace Davis4 games
June 30, 2016Rolando McClain10 games
June 30, 2016DeMarcus Lawrence4 games
June 30, 2016Johnny Manziel4 games
July 1, 2016Darren Waller4 games
July 15, 2016Aaron Lynch4 games
July 15, 2016Karlos Williams4 games
July 22, 2016Arthur Jones4 games
July 25, 2016Josh Gordon4 games
Aug. 16, 2016Marcell Dareus4 games
Aug. 17, 2016Zach Sterup4 games
Aug. 24, 2016Damion Square4 games
Aug. 30, 2016Sammie Lee Hill4 games
Sept. 2, 2016Rob Ninkovich4 games
Sept. 3, 2016Chris Scott4 games
Sept. 7, 2016Seantrel Henderson4 games
Sept. 15, 2016Nikita Whitlock10 games
Sept. 29, 2016Randy Gregory10 games
Oct. 11, 2016Lane Johnson10 games
Nov. 1, 2016Trent Williams4 games
Nov. 14, 2016Alshon Jeffery4 games
Nov. 20, 2016Rolando McClain16 games
Nov. 21, 2016Jerrell Freeman32 games
Nov. 21, 2016Jerrell Freeman4 games
Nov. 22, 2016Jude Adjei-Barimah4 games
Nov. 23, 2016Karlos Williams10 games
Nov. 29, 2016Seantrel Henderson10 games
Nov. 30, 2016Sammie Lee HillIndefinite
Dec. 2, 2016Rolando McClainIndefinite
Dec. 6, 2016D'Qwell Jackson4 games
Dec. 6, 2016Mike Pennel4 games
Dec. 9, 2016Jordan Payton4 games
Dec. 9, 2016Kenny Vaccaro4 games
Dec. 12, 2016Tenny Palepoi4 games
Dec. 29, 2016Doug Martin4 games
Jan. 5, 2017Randy Gregory

Entire 2017 season

Jan. 24, 2017J'Marcus Webb4 games
March 7, 2017Letroy Guion4 games
March 7, 2017Jalin Marshall4 games
March 9, 2017Kenneth Dixon4 games
March 15, 2017Austin Seferian-Jenkins4 games
March 29, 2017T. J. McDonald8 games
April 14, 2017Nick Marshall4 games
April 14, 2017Trent Murphy4 games
April 20, 2017Brandon Bostick4 games
April 21, 2017Shaquelle Evans4 games
May 4, 2017Max Bullough4 games
May 25, 2017Justin Gilbert4 games
June 1, 2017James Ihedigbo4 games
June 8, 2017Walter Powell4 games
June 20, 2017Khyri Thornton6 games
June 22, 2017Justin Gilbert

Entire 2017 season

June 28, 2017David Irving4 games
June 30, 2017Darren Waller

Entire 2017 season

July 14, 2017Michael Floyd4 games
July 14, 2017Mike Thomas4 games
July 18, 2017Armonty Bryant4 games
Aug. 6, 2017Jalen Collins10 games
Aug. 22, 2017Max Tuerk4 games
Aug. 28, 2017Owa Odighizuwa4 games
Sept. 13, 2017Brian Cushing10 games
Nov. 6, 2017Jeremy Kerley4 games
Nov. 20, 2017Marcus Gilbert4 games
Dec. 1, 2017Charles Johnson4 games
Dec. 4, 2017Jimmy Smith4 games
Dec. 23, 2017Khyri Thornton10 games
March 23, 2018Corey Liuget4 games
March 23, 2018Josh Mauro4 games
April 6, 2018Thomas Davis Sr.4 games
April 9, 2018Jalen Collins10 games
April 12, 2018Vontaze Burfict4 games
April 13, 2018Mark Sanchez4 games
April 20, 2018Kentrell Brothers4 games
April 20, 2018Kent Taylor4 games
April 30, 2018Cayleb Jones4 games
May 1, 2018Vadal Alexander4 games
May 4, 2018Akeem Ayers4 games
May 8, 2018Mark Ingram4 games
June 1, 2018Victor Bolden Jr.4 games
June 6, 2018Julian Edelman4 games
June 15, 2018David Irving4 games
June 29, 2018Robert Turbin4 games
July 25, 2018Rashard Robinson4 games
Sept. 1, 2018Daryl Worley4 games
Dec. 4, 2018Kyle Nelson10 games
Dec. 7, 2018Darron Lee4 games
Dec. 14, 2018Martavis BryantIndefinite
Dec. 20, 2018Josh GordonIndefinite
Feb. 26, 2019Randy GregoryIndefinite
March 1, 2019David IrvingIndefinite
May 14, 2019Dion Jordan10 games
May 16, 2019Patrick Peterson6 games
Dec. 16, 2019Josh GordonIndefinite
Nov. 30, 2020Will Fuller6 games
Nov. 30, 2020Bradley Roby6 games
April 3, 2021Tyrique McGhee5 games
June 17, 2021Chase HarrellEntire 2021 season
June 17, 2021Jordan Willis6 games
July 16, 2021David Onyemata6 games
Aug. 28, 2021Ryan Anderson6 games
Sept. 10, 2021La'el Collins5 games
Sept. 29, 2021Gerald McCoy6 games
Oct. 12, 2021Adrian Ealy6 games
Feb. 22, 2022Amani Bledsoe6 games
May 2, 2022DeAndre Hopkins6 games
June 1, 2022Andre Smith6 games
July 18, 2022Bobby Brown6 games

* Denotes suspension was later overturned.

MORE: Timeline of the Browns' starting QBs since 1999

Gambling suspensions under Roger Goodell

Only five players in NFL history have been suspended for gambling. Two of those suspensions came under Roger Goodell with the most notable one being Calvin Ridley.

Below are the two gambling suspensions that Goodell has overseen over the last few years. Each has lasted — or is slated to last — at least a year before the suspended player will be able to apply for reinstatement.

DatePlayerLength
Nov. 29, 2019Josh ShawEnd of 2019 season, entire 2020 season
March 8, 2022Calvin RidleyEntire 2022 season

Jacob Camenker

Jacob Camenker first joined The Sporting News as a fantasy football intern in 2018 after his graduation from UMass. He became a full-time employee with TSN in 2021 and now serves as a senior content producer with a particular focus on the NFL. Jacob worked at NBC Sports Boston as a content producer from 2019 to 2021. He is an avid fan of the NFL Draft and ranked 10th in FantasyPros’ Mock Draft Accuracy metric in both 2021 and 2022.