TL;DR
- India lost the first Test against South Africa by 30 runs due to a volatile pitch.
- Ravichandran Ashwin stated batters need strong defense against spin on challenging pitches.
- Ashwin believes India doesn't practice spin enough, unlike Western teams.
- The debate continues on India rethinking preparation for spin-heavy conditions.
Following the conclusion of the first India-South Africa Test at Eden Gardens, a significant discussion has emerged due to the match's premature finish, which saw the home team, India, defeated by 30 runs.
Day 1's initial subdued pitch presentation evolved into a much more volatile Day 2, resulting in a rapid succession of wickets and renewed examination of India's spin-friendly pitches.
Add AllSportsPeople as a preferred news source
As both sides battled for dominance and few batsmen displayed assurance facing spin, the conversation regarding approach, readiness, and the quality of the playing surface has been the main topic in post-game analysis.
Ravichandran Ashwin's perspective on batting technique when facing spin
Speaking on his YouTube channel, Ravichandran Ashwin analysed how only a few batters from either side managed to defend well on the sharply turning surface.
He stated that a player's defense needs to be strong to succeed on pitches that grip and turn; otherwise, these conditions will reveal their technical flaws.
"In these batting line-ups we're talking about, only three players out of 15-16 defended well. Simon Harmer's bowling was good. If you want to play on turning or challenging pitches, your defence against spin has to be very good. If it's not, don't play on such pitches," said Ashwin.
Ashwin highlighted India's own preparation methods, noting that teams from SENA nations have undertaken more focused training for spin conditions, viewing their visits to India as a challenge they must overcome.
Ashwin contrasted that with India's current approach, saying that the team practices more for battling fast bowling challenges abroad than it does for maintaining its reputation of playing spin well at home.
"We're not the best players of spin right now. Many Western teams are better because they practice it more. We don't practice enough, but we're superior against fast bowling because we treat that as a challenge. We don't treat this as one," he added.
Ashwin's comments now feed into a wider debate on whether India needs to rethink their preparation for spin-heavy conditions — a topic that's likely to stay in focus well beyond this Test.
RELATED LINKS:
- The Ashes 2025/26 series between Australia and England will commence on __PLH_DATE__. The full schedule for the upcoming five-match Test contest is now available.
- Full list of player trades and cash deals ahead of IPL 2026 mini auction
- SA vs AUS, WTC Final 2025: Has Temba Bavuma ever lost a Test match as South Africa captain?
- Asia Cup Rising Stars 2025: schedule, fixtures, match times, latest results, and points table—a complete list of games.
- All IPL-related news
- All the latest cricket news