Colts linked to $10 million promising backup quarterback as Daniel Jones' insurance

The Indianapolis Colts' quarterback situation is looking incredibly uncertain heading into the 2025 offseason.

When healthy, Daniel Jones looked like a franchise quarterback this year. However, he tore his Achilles tendon in Week 14 and is set to hit unrestricted free agency in the coming months.

Though the Colts want to retain Jones, and the veteran signal-caller is expected to return for training camp, it would still be wise for Indianapolis to add a high-level backup and insurance policy behind Jones.

That's why Sportsnaut's Matt Johnson predicts the Colts will sign Green Bay Packers free-agent quarterback Malik Willis this offseason.

Here is what Johnson had to say about Willis and why he makes sense in Indianapolis:

"Indianapolis needs an insurance plan, and that is Malik Willis. Willis would have the opportunity to compete for the starting job this offseason, receiving a majority of the first-team reps in minicamp until Jones returns. Plus, his athleticism and arm strength would make him an excellent fit in Shane Steichen’s offense."

Willis has been one of the best backup quarterbacks in football over the last two seasons. He went 2-0 as a starter in 2024, and though he didn't win a start in 2025, he completed 85.7% of his passes and tallied 3 touchdown passes with no interceptions when called upon.

The Liberty product also added 123 yards and two touchdowns on the ground, showcasing his dynamic skill set.

Riley Leonard showed flashes this year, but he isn't ready to be the No. 2 quarterback on a team with question marks at the position. Anthony Richardson has likely played his final down in a Colts uniform, so he is out of the equation.

Willis would be the perfect backup for Shane Steichen's squad, as he has mobility and has improved tremendously in the accuracy department. Additionally, the 26-year-old has experience as a starter and is always ready for the moment.

Spotrac projects Willis will land a one-year deal worth $10.6 million. Indianapolis is slated to have $33 million in cap space this offseason, so general manager Chris Ballard has plenty of money to sign Willis and ensure they have a stable quarterback situation in 2026.