The Cleveland Browns 5-12 season didn't go as planned, but the future has never looked brighter. ESPN’s Aaron Schatz officially ranked the Browns rookie class second in the NFL, trailing only the New Orleans Saints.
Cleveland's first-year players made histroy. They became the first team since 1970 to have rookies lead the roster in passing (Shedeur Sanders), rushing (Quinshon Judkins), receiving (Harold Fannin Jr.), and tackles (Carson Schwesinger). Judkins and Fannin also tied for most total touchdowns with seven.
Here's a complete breakdown of GM Andrew Berry's work:
Cleveland Browns 2025 Rookie Class
| Pick (Overall) | Player | Position | College |
| 1 (5) | Mason Graham | DT | Michigan |
| 2 (33) | Carson Schwesinger | LB | UCLA |
| 2 (36) | Quinshon Judkins | RB | Ohio State |
| 3 (67) | Harold Fannin Jr. | TE | Bowling Green |
| 3 (94) | Dillon Gabriel | QB | Oregon |
| 4 (126) | Dylan Sampson | RB | Tennessee |
| 5 (144) | Shedeur Sanders | QB | Colorado |
| UDFA | Adin Huntington | DT | Tulane |
| UDFA | Isaiah Bond | WR | Texas |
More: ESPN Insider: Current NFL coach is ‘75% favorite’ for Browns job
Let's take a closer look at the good and the bad from this 2025 group.
The Good: The crown jewel of the draft class is undeniably second-round linebacker Carson Schwesinger. The Defensive Rookie of the Year favorite was a tackling machine, racking up 156, as well as 2.5 sacks and 2.0 interceptions. Schatz noted that Schwesinger was "in a league of his own," while first-round DT Mason Graham grew into a strong interior anchor, ranking top-10 in the league for run-stop win rate.
On offensive side of the ball, Harold Fannin Jr. Was a revelation at tight end with his bulldog like demeanor to always earn tough extra yards after the catch.
The Bad: It wasn't all perfect. While Shedeur Sanders flashed elite potential--becoming the first rookie since Joe Burrow to post a 350/3/1 stat line--ESPN noted his production "did not knock it out of the park" consistently. Sanders struggled behind an injury-plagued O-line, finishing with more interceptions (10) than touchdowns (7) over his seven starts.
The draft pick QB taken two rounds ahead of Sanders, Dillon Gabriel, was a non-factor when it came to moving the ball during his six starts.
The Verdict; Despite the "bad" quarterback play overall, the sheer volume of production from this rookie class is undeniable. The draft crop filled four starting spots and can be the foundation upon which a new head coach can build up from. As Schatz put it, this draft "can turn a franchise around."
Browns fans desperately hope that is true.
More Browns News:
- Mike Tomlin to the Browns? Why the Steelers legend will never coach in Cleveland
- It’s Over: The ‘dealbreaker’ that kept John Harbaugh from coaching the Browns
- Ranking Browns head coach coordinator candidates: Why Grant Udinski and Dan Pitcher lead the pack
- Browns mock draft round-up: Ty Simpson at No. 6? A 'shocking' first-round gamble
- Living in his car to NFL head coach? The meteoric rise of Browns candidate Grant Udinski