Why did Bills fire Sean McDermott? Buffalo makes seismic change after another playoff exit

Dan Treacy

Why did Bills fire Sean McDermott? Buffalo makes seismic change after another playoff exit image

Less than 48 hours after seeing their season end in the divisional round for the fourth time in five years, the Buffalo Bills are making a massive change.

Buffalo fired coach Sean McDermott on Monday after nine seasons, NFL Network's Tom Pelissero reported, opting against staying the course following yet another deflating playoff exit.

McDermott went 98-50 with the Bills, reaching the playoffs eight times after taking over a franchise with a 17-year playoff drought. With Josh Allen at quarterback, however, Buffalo has failed to reach the Super Bowl, let alone win one.

Here's what you need to know about McDermott's firing in Buffalo.

MORE: Every NFL head coaching change in 2026

Why did the Bills fire Sean McDermott?

For several years, the Bills have avoided major changes despite repeated playoff disappointment, staying the course at quarterback, head coach and largely in the coordinator roles as well even without reaching their Super Bowl goals.

While Buffalo only narrowly lost to the AFC's No. 1 seed in the divisional round this year, another disappointing January simply appeared to be the breaking point for the franchise.

With Allen consistently playing like one of the NFL's elite quarterbacks and Patrick Mahomes missing the playoffs entirely this season, this was expected to be the year in which the Bills had their clearest path to an AFC championship. Instead, they appeared to be stuck in neutral in the playoffs.

The Bills know they can essentially have their choice of major candidates because Allen makes the job so attractive, and they are confirming that they are no longer satisfied with anything less than a deep playoff run by axing McDermott after nine years.

Still, the decision to fire McDermott likely didn't come lightly. The veteran coach took over a team that hadn't even been to the playoffs in the 21st century when he was hired in 2017 and went to the playoffs seven times, averaging just under 11 wins per season. As attractive as the Bills job will be, the next head coach in Buffalo will walk into the new stadium knowing anything less than a Super Bowl appearance would be a disappointment. 

MORE: Picks, predictions for conference championship games

Sean McDermott coaching record

SeasonWLPct.
201797.563
2018610.375
2019106.625
2020133.813
2021116.647
2022133.813
2023116.647
2024134.765
2025125.706
Career9850.662

McDermott went 98-50 in nine seasons with the Bills, winning 10.9 games per season and reaching the playoffs eight times. He is Buffalo's second-winningest coach, behind only Marv Levy.

MORE: How Josh Allen was nearly drafted by Broncos

Sean McDermott playoff record

SeasonWLResult
201701Lost in wild-card round
201800Missed playoffs
201901Lost in wild-card round
202021Lost in AFC championship
202111Lost in divisional round
202211Lost in divisional round
202311Lost in divisional round
202421Lost in AFC championship
202511Lost in divisional round
Career88.500

McDermott was 8-8 across 16 playoff games with the Bills, reaching the AFC championship game twice but never advancing to the Super Bowl. Buffalo was 0-4 against Mahomes and the Kansas City Chiefs in the playoffs despite plenty of regular season success against the two-time MVP.

The Bills lost in the divisional round in four of McDermott's final five seasons.

MORE: Josh Allen, Bills players get emotional after loss to Broncos

How old is Sean McDermott?

McDermott is 51 years old. He is set to turn 52 on March 21.

As the NFL goes younger in the head coaching role, McDermott will be an intriguing veteran option for teams, whether in this current coaching cycle or in future cycles.

How long did Sean McDermott coach the Bills?

McDermott spent nine seasons as head coach of the Bills. At the time of his firing, he was the NFL's second longest-tenured coach behind only Andy Reid following the exits of Mike Tomlin from Pittsburgh and John Harbaugh from Baltimore.

The Bills had a 17-year playoff drought when McDermott was hired, but he reached the playoffs eight times in nine years in western New York. 

Senior Content Producer

Senior Editor