Penn State quarterback Drew Allar found himself at the center of sharp criticism following the Nittany Lions’ 30-24 double-overtime loss to Oregon on Saturday night. His final throw was a game-sealing interception on Penn State’s possession in the second overtime. The error axed what had been a comeback attempt against the sixth-ranked Ducks.
Allar’s stat line told the story of the night Penn State. He went 14-of-25 passing for 137 yards and two touchdowns. Both to Devonte Ross, which kept the Nittany Lions alive late. Allar orchestrating a 15-play, nearly seven-minute drive capped by the game-tying score with just 30 seconds left in regulation. But in the unforgiving world of college football, one mistake overshadowed the resilience.
Fans took to social media almost immediately and many pointed out the interception as evidence of Penn State’s offensive struggles against top-tier opponents.
Some posts called the quarterback “too conservative” and criticized his lack of downfield production, while others noted the pressure of the "white out" atmosphere and Oregon’s defensive speed contributed to the costly decision.
Drew Allar now falls to 0-6 against AP Top-6 ranked opponents after No. 3 Penn State's loss to No. 6 Oregon. pic.twitter.com/zZ38nt7sd0
— ESPN Insights (@ESPNInsights) September 28, 2025
Drew Allar with a game-losing interception in his last two big games. Wow.
— Chris Vannini (@ChrisVannini) September 28, 2025
A James Franklin led Penn State team lost a big time game? pic.twitter.com/45q98AFPZV
— Josh (@_Philly_Talk) September 28, 2025
Drew Allar could be a GREAT NFL QB if he becomes way better at football
— Ian Hartitz (@Ihartitz) September 28, 2025
Penn State fans have started chanting “Fire Franklin.” pic.twitter.com/7fbERwNxOW
— Joe Smeltzer (@joesmeltzer775) September 28, 2025
Penn State’s last 3 losses have all ended essentially on a Drew Allar interception.
— Penn State FB Thoughts (@PSU_FB_Thoughts) September 28, 2025
Drew Allar pic.twitter.com/pvQzhOmCiU
— Jake (@SuperiorNBA) September 28, 2025
Was this the best throw of Drew Allar's career?pic.twitter.com/eB9dWFe10v
— Tom Fornelli (@TomFornelli) September 28, 2025
Drew Allar in a “throw game losing INTs” contest pic.twitter.com/dbVcTw8F8U
— Iveysaur (@Ivey_GOAT1617) September 28, 2025
penn state when they realized they could throw the ball: pic.twitter.com/oR6q8eGVgW
— xx (@ItMeJaren) September 28, 2025
Drew Allar is the most Iowa QB to never play there. Dudes just big and sucks so bad
— joey wheelah (@NyehJoeyWheelah) September 28, 2025
Drew Allar and James Franklin when it comes to losing against ranked teams pic.twitter.com/v3UKrhKU9j
— John (@jrm71588) September 28, 2025
Drew Allar and James Franklin when they have to play a team that also has a NIL program pic.twitter.com/mGJDc85Jcy
— Steve_Jets (@SportsBurner130) September 28, 2025
Drew Allar is the James Franklin of Penn State Quarterbacks pic.twitter.com/jvO9Kgtr6y
— Official Ohio State DG (@DylanEveryday) September 28, 2025
Allar’s ability to rally his team in crunch time and reminding critics that Penn State would not have reached double overtime without his steady hand. His chemistry with Ross, who caught both touchdown passes, was a bright spot on an otherwise uneven night.
For Penn State head coach James Franklin and his staff, the focus now turns to shoring up the passing attack as Big Ten play his. Penn State sits at 3-1 (0-1 Big Ten) and must rebound quickly to keep conference championship aspirations intact. Allar knows every throw can define a season.
The loss might be a wakeup call for Penn State, who have dreams of returning to the College Football Playoff.
MORE COLLEGE FOOTBALL NEWS:
- Deion Sanders buyout, contract details as Colorado Buffaloes coach
- Lane Kiffin trash talks daughter's LSU linebacker boyfriend in postgame interview
- Virginia knocks off No. 9 Florida State 46-38 double overtime thriller
- Mike Norvell buyout, contract details as Florida State Seminoles coach
- Dangerous field storm follows Virginia upset of Florida State