Miami's playoff seed a hoax?

The Week 13 College Football Playoff rankings have been released, and Miami is once again positioned within the playoff field. The Hurricanes are currently ranked 11th and are scheduled to face Ole Miss away from home. However, before supporters become overly optimistic, it's crucial to grasp the reasons behind Miami's elevated seeding. The revised playoff structure awards automatic berths to the five conference champions with the top rankings. For instance, Tulane, despite being ranked 24th, holds the 12th seed due to their lead in the American Athletic Conference. Miami, ranked 13th overall, is the highest-ranked team in the ACC, which consequently enhances their temporary playoff standing.

Here’s the catch, Miami currently sits sixth in the ACC standings with slim chances of winning the conference. So, is Miami’s playoff seeding a true reflection of their season, or is it, as some say, a bit of a hoax?

The revamped playoff system aims to promote diversity by rewarding conference champions. While this sounds fair, it often inflates teams’ seeds based more on conference affiliation than on-field performance. Under the old format, Miami would likely be seeded much lower or even excluded at this point. This creates a gap between where a team is ranked and how well they actually played during the season.

This year, Miami's actual performance has fallen short of playoff expectations. The Hurricanes have struggled with inconsistency, including developmental challenges with their transfer quarterback. Injuries and significant defeats against teams like SMU and Louisville have placed them behind several ACC opponents. Their track record doesn't strongly suggest a playoff contender, which supports the view that their current seeding is not an accurate reflection of their standing.

Miami isn't the only team in this situation. Other franchises with mediocre or losing season records gain entry through the automatic bid system by topping less competitive conferences. This sparks debate regarding the fairness of the playoffs and if the system genuinely selects the top teams or just those who win their conferences.

Many fans and analysts have criticized Miami’s seeding as a loophole, calling into question the credibility of the playoff rankings. This “hoax” seeding risks alienating fans and impacting how college football’s championship system is viewed nationally.

To remove the “hoax” designation, Miami must demonstrate their capabilities on the field by improving their standing in the ACC and securing the conference title. Until that occurs, their playoff inclusion seems more like a procedural matter than a reflection of a championship-level team.

More college football news: 

• Deion Sanders buyout, contract details as Colorado Buffaloes coach
• Ole Miss reportedly gives Lane Kiffin an ultimatum as family visits Florida and LSU
• Virginia Tech reportedly funding roster near top of ACC for James Franklin
• Bill Belichick goes viral for awkward handshake after Wake Forest loss
• Texas state trooper reportedly relieved of duties after player exchange at Texas A&M