Yankees could replace Devin Williams with MLB saves leader as ERA tops 10

Peter Chawaga

Yankees could replace Devin Williams with MLB saves leader as ERA tops 10 image

The New York Yankees have a lot to celebrate about their latest blockbuster offseason, but some of the moves haven’t worked out.

Signing Max Fried appears to have been invaluable as he’s filled in admirably for the loss of franchise ace Gerrit Cole. And the addition of Paul Goldschmidt has offered a critical running mate for Aaron Judge.

But in hindsight, trading for two-time National League Reliever of the Year Devin Williams might have been a mistake. 

After his latest appearance on Monday against the San Diego Padres, Williams now has a 10.03 ERA across 14 games this season and it might be time to look into acquiring a new closer.

As the Yankees assess the trade landscape, they could settle on 2024 Major League Baseball saves leader Ryan Helsley, who is likely to be on the trade block as the St. Louis Cardinals rebuild and he heads into free agency at the end of the season.

“With an urgent need for a closer in the Yankees’ lineup, Helsley certainly fits into the system as an elite game-changer,” Shubro Mukherjee explained for Essentially Sports. “He has constantly proven his pedigree by regularly hitting 100+ mph fastballs. Furthermore, the Yankees do not have to worry about bloated long-term deals, as Helsley is still under team control through 2025 via arbitration.”

Follow The Sporting News On WhatsApp

So far in 2025, Helsley seems to have lost some of his mojo, though not to the degree of Williams. He has a 3.75 ERA with five saves in eight games finished so far. But if the Yankees feel like Helsley can handle some high-leverage situations in New York, they might see him as a needed upgrade as the playoffs get closer.

More MLB: Red Sox predicted to move Rafael Devers in conclusion of season-long drama

Peter Chawaga

Peter Chawaga is a veteran journalist covering Major League Baseball for The Sporting News. His MLB reporting has included feature interviews with commissioner Rob Manfred and Hall of Fame slugger David Ortiz, salary analysis, player rankings and more. He has covered baseball for Forbes, Yardbarker, Pitcher List, Athlon and other outlets.

With over ten years of newsroom experience, he has previously covered finance, technology, arts, and culture for newspapers, magazines, and websites nationwide. He graduated from Wake Forest University with a degree in English and journalism.