Fantasy Baseball RP Rankings: Closer Tiers, Sleepers, Draft Strategy

Matt Lutovsky

Fantasy Baseball RP Rankings: Closer Tiers, Sleepers, Draft Strategy image

Everyone knows closers are the worst, so it's fair to wonder why most fantasy baseball leagues still have saves as a category. Even if your league has made the switch to saves and holds as one category -- which really opens up the player pool to include all relief pitchers and causes much less draft-day or in-season stress -- those third-of-an-inning, four-run implosions really sting. Nevertheless, most leagues still have saves, and therefore most owners need a good set of RP rankings heading into draft day. 

Every season it gets more difficult to rank relievers. Roughly two-thirds of closers lose their jobs, at least temporarily, at some point each year. That might be because of injury or poor performance, but either way, there's going to be significant turnover. On top of that, more teams seem to be opting for a "closer-by-committee" strategy in the late innings, which ultimately adds more potential saves contributors but also makes it more difficult to find the right ones. There are only so many spots on a roster, and you can't devote too many to RPs who might get one save chance per week. 

DOMINATE YOUR DRAFT: 2021 Fantasy Baseball Cheat Sheet

Our RP rankings elevate the "safe" closers, but even our No. 2 guy, Josh Hader, might be in more of a committee than you think. His K-rate and peripherals are so good, though, that he can still be a major contributor in any type of league. The same goes for his bullpen-mate Devin Williams, who could also find himself in the mix for saves. Perhaps we have him overvalued, but that just shows how difficult it is to navigate this position. There aren't many "sure things" for saves, and there are even fewer "sure things" who will actually have good ERAs and WHIPs. 

2021 FANTASY BASEBALL RANKINGS:
Catcher | First | Second | Third | Short | Outfield | Starter | Top 300

RP is an important position, but it's the toughest position to handicap in March. That means you shouldn't invest too much draft capital into it. Yes, you want a stud closer, maybe even two, but unless they have ultra-high K-rates and have proven themselves over the past seasons, you shouldn't reach too far. There will be plenty of closers who pop up on the waiver wire throughout the year, and if you trust yourself to get them, then there's no need to pass on more reliable hitters or starters. 

2021 FANTASY SLEEPERS
Catcher | First | Second | Third | Short | Outfield | Pitcher | Each Team

We'll be updating these RP rankings frequently throughout the spring, so check back for the latest player movement. 

MORE FANTASY BASEBALL:
Mock Draft Simulator | Auction Values | Team Names | Spring Updates

Fantasy Baseball RP Rankings: Closer Tiers, Sleepers, Draft Strategy

Rankings based on 5x5 H2H leagues with Ks, ERA, WHIP, Wins, and Saves as pitching categories. 

Position eligibility based on Yahoo's default settings

RankPlayer (throws)Age (as of 4/1)TeamTier
1Liam Hendricks (R)32White Sox1
2Josh Hader (L)26Brewers1
3James Karinchak (R)25Indians1
4Aroldis Chapman (L)33Yankees1
5Brad Hand (L)31Nationals2
6Raisel Iglesias (R)31Angels2
7Edwin Diaz (R)27Mets2
8Ryan Pressly (R)32Astros2
9Kenley Jansen (R)33Dodgers2
10Nick Anderson (R)30Rays2
11Devin Williams (R)26Brewers3
12Hector Neris (R)31Phillies3
13Richard Rodriguez (R)31Pirates3
14Drew Pomeranz (L)32Padres3
15Trevor Rosenthal (R)30A's3
16Greg Holland (R)35Royals4
17Jordan Romano (R)27Blue Jays4
18Matt Barnes (R)30Red Sox4
19Giovanny Gallegos (R)29Cardinals4
20Amir Garrett (L)28Reds4
21Taylor Rogers (L)30Twins4
22Anthony Bass (R)33Marlins5
23Emilio Pagan (R)29Padres5
24Diego Castillo (R)27Rays5
25Jordan Hicks (R)24Cardinals5
26Alex Colome (R)32Twins5
27Craig Kimbrel (R)32Cubs5
28Joakim Soria (R)36D-backs5
29Rafael Montero (R)30Mariners5
30Will Smith (L)31Braves6
31Daniel Bard (R)35Rockies6
32Jake McGee (L)34Giants6
33Stefan Crichton (R)29D-backs6
34Sean Doolittle (L)34Reds6
35Bryan Garcia (R)25Tigers6
36Hunter Harvey (R)26Orioles6
37Matt Bush (R)35Rangers7
38Ian Kennedy (R)36Rangers7
39Daniel Hudson (R)34Nationals7
40Yimi Garcia (R)30Marlins7
41Luke Jackson (R)29Braves7
42Mike Mayers (R)29Angels8
43Freddy Peralta (R)24Brewers8
44Archie Bradley (R)28Phillies8
45A.J. Minter (L)27Braves8
46Scott Oberg (R)31Rockies8
47Jose Cisnero (R)31Tigers8
48Luke Jackson (R)29Braves8
49Zack Britton (L)33Yankees8
50Tejay Antone (R)27Reds8
51Cesar Valdez (R)36Orioles8
52Jose Leclerc (R)27Rangers8

Matt Lutovsky

Matt Lutovsky has been a writer and editor for The Sporting News since 2007, primarily writing about fantasy sports, betting, and gaming.