Every perfect passer rating in NFL history: Full list of 158.3 QB performances, from Tom Brady to Josh Allen

Dan Treacy

Every perfect passer rating in NFL history: Full list of 158.3 QB performances, from Tom Brady to Josh Allen image

JUMP TO: 


No stat can quite capture the full impact of an NFL quarterback. 

Not only is leadership and poise critical to success at the position, but every quarterback in the league is impacted by the players around him, whether negatively or positively.

Passer rating can't account for how much or how little help a quarterback receives, but it takes the stats and attempts to sum up a quarterback's performance in one, simple number. On rare occasions, quarterbacks have mastered the art of the passer rating.

Here's what you need to know about a perfect passer rating in the NFL and which quarterbacks have achieved it.

MORE: Full guide to NFL passer rating stat, from history, formula, records and more

What is a perfect passer rating in the NFL?

On occasion, a quarterback's performance in one game is so impressive that he achieves a perfect passer rating of 158.3. While the number might sound obscure, it's what every quarterback aims for — along with the win, of course.

A perfect passer rating is more complicated than a quarterback completing all or nearly all of his passes. Jared Goff finished 18-of-18 in a prime-time win over the Seattle Seahawks in 2024 but did not record a perfect passer rating because his touchdown rate wasn't high enough.

Here is a look at the numbers required to achieve a perfect passer rating.

MORE: Inside the NFL's concussion protocol

NFL perfect passer rating requirements

A perfect passer rating requires the following:

  • Min. 10 pass attempts
  • Min. 77.5% completion rate
  • Min. 11.875% of passes result in touchdowns
  • Min. 12.5 yards per attempt

Passer rating is entirely numbers-based, so there is no scorekeeper behind the scenes making the decision to give any player a perfect passer rating. 

MORE: Explaining the NFL's updated kickoff rules

Perfect passer rating games in NFL history

Here's a look at every perfect passer rating game in history. Although the passer rating metric was created in 1973, the formula has been applied to previous games as well. 

QBDateTeamOpponentComp./Att.YardsTD
Ray MalloufOct. 17, 1948CardinalsGiants14/182524
Sammy BaughOct. 16, 1949RedskinsBulldogs16/202544
Otto GrahamOct. 10, 1954BrownsCardinals14/182663
George RattermanNov. 7, 1954BrownsRedskins10/112083
Milt PlumOct. 5, 1958BrownsSteelers13/141972
M.C. ReynoldsDec. 5, 1959CardinalsLions8/101702
Len DawsonSept. 7, 1963ChiefsBroncos12/152784
Y.A. TittleNov. 10, 1963GiantsEagles16/202613
Frank RyanDec. 12, 1964BrownsGiants12/132025
Sonny JurgensenOct. 24, 1965RedskinsCardinals12/141953
Joe NamathOct. 22, 1967JetsDolphins13/151992
Johnny UnitasNov. 12, 1967ColtsFalcons17/203704
Don MeredithDec. 24, 1967*CowboysBrowns10/122122
Craig MortonOct. 5, 1969CowboysEagles14/182613
Fran TarkentonOct. 25, 1970GiantsCardinals15/182805
Daryle LamonicaSept. 17, 1972RaidersSteelers8/101722
Dick ShinerSept. 16, 1973FalconsSaints13/252273
Bob LeeOct. 14, 1973FalconsBears11/131812
James HarrisOct. 20, 1974Rams49ers12/152763
Ken AndersonNov. 3, 1974BengalsColts17/212973
Jim HartNov. 23, 1975CardinalsJets11/132422
Dan FoutsSept. 26, 1976ChargersCardinals15/182594
Scott HunterOct. 31, 1976FalconsSaints10/112382
Terry BradshawDec. 19, 1976*SteelersColts14/182643
Steve GroganOct. 29, 1978PatriotsJets15/192814
Brian SipeOct. 29, 1978BrownsBills12/152173
Bob GrieseDec. 18, 1978DolphinsPatriots12/131712
Vince EvansDec. 7, 1980BearsPackers18/223163
Craig MortonSept. 27, 1981BroncosChargers17/183084
Dave KriegDec. 24, 1983*SeahawksBroncos12/132003
Steve BartkowskiSept. 23, 1984FalconsOilers11/131953
Ken O'BrienNov. 2, 1986JetsSeahawks26/324314
Steve YoungOct. 22, 198949ersPatriots11/121882
Joe MontanaNov. 12, 198949ersFalcons16/192703
Ken O'BrienDec. 23, 1990JetsPatriots11/122102
Rich GannonOct. 15, 1992VikingsLions8/101462
Bobby HebertSept. 12, 1993FalconsSaints14/182433
Mike BuckOct. 17, 1993SaintsSteelers10/111642
Drew BledsoeDec. 26, 1993PatriotsColts9/111432
Craig EricksonOct. 11, 1994BuccaneersColts19/243133
Dave KriegNov. 24, 1994LionsBills20/253513
Chris ChandlerSept. 25, 1995OilersBengals23/263524
Jeff BlakeOct. 19, 1995BengalsSteelers18/222753
Kurt WarnerOct. 3, 1999RamsBengals17/213103
Kurt WarnerOct. 1, 2000RamsChargers24/303914
Peyton ManningOct. 22, 2000ColtsPatriots16/202683
Doug FlutieDec. 24, 2000BillsSeahawks20/253663
Peyton ManningNov. 10, 2002ColtsEagles18/233193
Kerry CollinsDec. 22, 2002GiantsColts23/293664
Peyton ManningSept. 28, 2003ColtsSaints20/253146
Chad PenningtonNov. 16, 2003JetsColts11/142193
Trent GreenDec. 14, 2003ChiefsLions20/253413
Peyton ManningJan. 4, 2004*ColtsBroncos22/263775
Ben RoethlisbergerSept. 11, 2005SteelersTitans9/112182
Donovan McNabbSept. 23, 2007EaglesLions21/263814
Tom BradyOct. 21, 2007PatriotsDolphins21/253546
Ben RoethlisbergerNov. 5, 2007SteelersRavens13/162095
Ben RoethlisbergerDec. 20, 2007SteelersRams16/203613
Kurt WarnerSept. 14, 2008CardinalsDolphins19/243613
Eli ManningOct. 11, 2009GiantsRaiders8/101732
Drew BreesNov. 30, 2009SaintsPatriots18/233715
Tom BradyNov. 25, 2010PatriotsLions21/273414
Robert Griffin IIINov. 18, 2012RedskinsEagles14/152004
Nick FolesNov. 3, 2013EaglesRaiders22/284067
Alex SmithDec. 15, 2013ChiefsRaiders17/202875
Geno SmithDec. 28, 2014JetsDolphins20/253583
Marcus MariotaSept. 13, 2015TitansBuccaneers13/162094
Ryan TannehillOct. 25, 2015DolphinsTexans18/192824
Kirk CousinsNov. 15, 2015RedskinsTitans20/253244
Jared GoffSept. 27, 2018RamsVikings26/334655
Russell WilsonOct. 28, 2018SeahawksLions14/172483
Ben RoethlisbergerNov. 8, 2018SteelersPanthers22/253285
Lamar JacksonSept. 8, 2019RavensDolphins17/203245
Dak PrescottSept. 8, 2019CowboysGiants25/324054
Deshaun WatsonOct. 6, 2019TexansFalcons28/334265
Aaron RodgersOct. 20, 2019PackersRaiders25/314295
Lamar JacksonNov. 10, 2019RavensBengals15/172233
Tom BradyDec. 26, 2020BuccaneersLions22/273484
Josh AllenOct. 1, 2023BillsDolphins21/253204
Brock PurdyNov. 19, 202349ersBuccaneers21/253333
Baker MayfieldDec. 17, 2023BuccaneersPackers22/283814
Lamar JacksonDec. 31, 2023RavensDolphins18/213215
Kyler MurraySept. 15, 2024CardinalsRams17/212663
Lamar JacksonNov. 3, 2024RavensBroncos16/192803
Jared GoffNov. 17, 2024LionsJaguars24/294124

* — Playoff game

MORE: Most Super Bowl wins in history by player

Players with multiple perfect passer rating games

Nine players have achieved a perfect passer rating game multiple times, including the playoffs, led by Peyton Manning, Lamar Jackson and Ben Roethlisberger's four each. Here is the full leaderboard:

QBPerfect passer rating gamesTeam(s)
Lamar Jackson4Ravens
Peyton Manning4Colts
Ben Roethlisberger4Steelers
Tom Brady3Patriots, Buccaneers
Kurt Warner3Rams, Cardinals
Jared Goff2Rams, Lions
Dave Krieg2Lions, Seahawks
Craig Morton2Cowboys, Broncos
Ken O'Brien2Jets

MORE: What to know about NFL scorigami meaning, history and more

Perfect passer ratings in the NFL playoffs

Four quarterbacks have achieved a perfect passer rating in the playoffs.

Don Meredith, Cowboys (1967)

  • Score: Cowboys 52, Browns 14
  • Stats: 11/13, 212 yards, 2 TD

Don Meredith made NFL history with the first perfect passer rating playoff game when he threw for 212 yards and a pair of touchdowns on 11 completions in a resounding win over the Cleveland Browns to advance to the NFL championship game. The performance was the only perfect passer rating game of Meredith's career.

Terry Bradshaw, Steelers (1976)

  • Score: Steelers 40, Colts 14
  • Stats: 14/18, 264 yards, 3 TD

Pittsburgh Steelers legend Terry Bradshaw's only perfect passer rating game came in the playoffs, when he threw for 264 yards and three touchdowns on 14 completions in a road blowout of the Colts. The success was short-lived, as Bradshaw would go on to struggle in an AFC championship loss to the Raiders that saw Pittsburgh score only seven points.

Dave Krieg, Seahawks (1983)

  • Score: Seahawks 31, Broncos 7
  • Stats: 12/13, 200 yards, 3 TD

Dave Krieg was just about perfect in his first career playoff start, tossing only one incompletion in a blowout win over the Broncos to push the Seahawks to the divisional round. Krieg is one of two players in NFL history with a perfect passer rating game in both the regular season and playoffs, as he recorded his second such performance with the Lions in 1994.

Peyton Manning, Colts (2003)

  • Score: Colts 41, Broncos 10
  • Stats: 22/26, 377 yards, 5 TD

Peyton Manning was brilliant in the Colts' playoff opener in 2003, throwing for 377 yards and five touchdowns in a blowout win over his future team. The performance gave Manning the fourth perfect passer rating game of his career, though he would surprisingly never record another. 

MORE: Comparing overtime rules for the preseason, regular season and postseason

How rare is a perfect passer rating?

Perfect passer ratings have been recorded in just 0.24 percent of all quarterback starts in NFL history — or about one in every 423 starts.

Pro Football Reference counts roughly 18,000 total games in NFL history, including the playoffs. Each game has two starting quarterbacks, which pushes the total to nearly 36,000 quarterback starts in NFL history. With only 85 perfect passer rating games on the books, the average comes out to the miniscule figure of one per every 4we starts.

MORE: What is a catch in the NFL? Explaining NFL's controversial rule

Perfect passer rating FAQs

Who is the youngest QB to record a perfect passer rating? 

Robert Griffin III became the youngest quarterback to achieve a perfect passer rating when he went 14-of-15 for 200 yards and four touchdowns against the Philadelphia Eagles on Nov. 18, 2012. Griffin, a rookie at the time, was only 22 years old. 

Who is the oldest QB to record a perfect passer rating?

Tom Brady became the oldest quarterback to achieve a perfect passer rating when he finished 22-of-27 for 348 yards and four touchdowns against the Detroit Lions on Dec, 26, 2020. Brady was 43 years old at the time.

Which team has given up the most perfect passer ratings? 

The Dolphins and Lions have each allowed seven perfect passer rating games in their history, tied for the most all time.

Which team has given up the least perfect passer ratings?

The Dallas Cowboys and Kansas City Chiefs are the only two NFL teams who have never allowed a perfect passer rating game.

MORE: Explaining unsportsmanlike conduct penalties in the NFL

Which team has recorded the most perfect passer ratings?

Three teams are tied for the most perfect passer rating games, and two are ones you would least expect: the Browns and Jets, in addition to the Falcons. The caveat is Cleveland's last perfect passer rating came in 1978, and that is the franchise's only perfect passer rating after 1964; the Browns have not had any perfect passer rating games since the newest iteration of their franchise was founded in 1999.

Four quarterbacks make up five perfect passer rating games for the perpetually quarterback-starved Jets, including two from Ken O'Brien, while the Falcons have seen five different quarterbacks achieve a perfect passer rating but none since 1993. 

Which team has recorded the least perfect passer ratings?

The Carolina Panthers and Jacksonville Jaguars are the only NFL teams without a perfect passer rating game in their history.

The Panthers and Jaguars are fairly new franchises by NFL standards, as they both made their debuts in 1995, but that still means more than three decades have passed without a perfect passer rating game for two teams that have historically had a difficult time finding solutions at quarterback.

MORE: Everything to know about the NFL's personal conduct policy

Dan Treacy

Dan Treacy is a content producer for Sporting News, joining in 2022 after graduating from Boston University. He founded @allsportsnews on Instagram in 2012 and has written for Lineups and Yardbarker.