Bailey Smith’s turbulent few weeks have left Geelong and the AFL facing an uncomfortable question: how much longer can they defend their star player’s actions?
The 24-year-old has been formally warned by the league over his recent social media conduct, with the AFL reportedly ready to hand down punishment if the negative posts continue.
Smith has been at the centre of multiple controversies, from his part in Geelong’s Mad Monday celebrations to sharing a clip of The Footy Show where Sam Newman criticised journalist Caroline Wilson. The incidents have prompted fresh scrutiny of both the player’s judgement and the club’s handling of him.
MORE: Bailey Smith incidents: List of indiscretions involving Geelong star
Cornes calls for accountability
Footy pundit Kane Cornes believes it’s time Smith faced the consequences. “Where does this leave Geelong and the AFL’s confidence in them being able to handle Bailey Smith – not great,” Cornes said on SEN Breakfas t. “They’re obviously slightly worried about it... How much will they continue to let him get away with? What happens if there’s another social post?”
Cornes added that while Smith has spoken publicly about his mental health challenges, that cannot be used as a shield. “The thing that’s difficult to comment on is when mental health comes into it,” he said. “Because you have a mental health issue, which you’re open about, it doesn’t excuse being disrespectful.”
The saga has also exposed cracks within Geelong’s response, with club CEO Steve Hocking’s comments about Smith’s social media use drawing criticism. Cornes argued that Hocking “needs to start understanding social media”, adding pointedly, “You’re the CEO of a footy club. Your players live in this world. It’s a key component of your job to do that, get your head around it.”