Patriots-Bills Picks, SNF Betting Preview & NFL Sportsbook Odds

Get the best Patriots vs Bills picks and predictions for betting on the Week 5 Sunday Night Football matchup featuring two AFC East rivals.

• Buffalo enters as an 8-point home favorite, but New England has dominated this rivalry against the spread, covering in four straight meetings. The game total sits at 49.5 points, despite the over connecting in four of the last five head-to-head battles.
• Injuries will heavily influence this Sunday Night Football showdown, particularly Buffalo's depleted defense. With key contributors like Matt Milano and Ed Oliver limited, the Patriots' methodical ground attack has a prime opportunity to exploit a weakened Bills front seven and control possession.
• A classic "sharps versus public" scenario is developing on the total. While recreational bettors are hammering the Under 49.5, a commanding 70.94% of the money is backing the Over, signaling professional action believes this exceptionally low number offers significant value.

A clash of contrasting philosophies takes center stage under the Sunday Night Football lights as the undefeated Buffalo Bills welcome their AFC East nemesis, the New England Patriots, to Highmark Stadium. This Week 5 divisional battle features two teams traveling vastly different paths. Buffalo has torched opponents with their high-octane aerial attack, averaging 33.2 points and 404 yards per game behind superstar quarterback Josh Allen.

Meanwhile, New England has methodically ground out victories with second-year signal-caller Drake Maye, producing a more modest 25 points and 336.2 yards per contest while maintaining superior ball security with a +3 turnover differential compared to Buffalo's concerning -3 mark.

The storylines surrounding this primetime showdown run deeper than contrasting offensive approaches. The emotional centerpiece revolves around Patriots wide receiver Stefon Diggs returning to Buffalo for the first time since his departure, creating a revenge-game narrative that has captivated the football world.

Compounding the intrigue are significant defensive injuries plaguing both squads, with Buffalo's linebacker Matt Milano and defensive tackle Ed Oliver both limited by injuries that could fundamentally alter the game's complexion.

This comprehensive breakdown will dissect the betting landscape, analyze critical matchup advantages, examine the player prop market, and deliver expert predictions for this pivotal AFC East battle that could reshape the division's hierarchy.

New users can sign-up with the BetMGM bonus code TSN150 to claim a $150 bonus or $1,500 first bet for this matchup.

Patriots vs Bills Betting Preview

The Patriots venture into hostile territory for their Week 5 showdown against the Bills at Highmark Stadium. Buffalo has established offensive dominance through four games, torching defenses for 33.2 points and 404 yards per game with their explosive passing attack.

The Patriots have countered with a more conservative approach, averaging 25 points and 336.2 yards per contest while excelling in the turnover battle with a season-long +3 differential that stands in stark contrast to Buffalo's troublesome -3 mark. Despite their offensive differences, both teams have proven equally lethal in the red zone, converting 66.7% of their scoring opportunities into touchdowns.

Patriots vs Bills Betting Odds

Odds as of October 4, 2025 from DraftKings.

The NFL betting market has established Buffalo as a decisive home favorite, with the moneyline implying overwhelming confidence in the undefeated Bills. However, the point spread reveals a more nuanced story that savvy bettors should recognize.

New England has consistently outperformed expectations in this rivalry, covering the spread in four consecutive meetings while Buffalo has failed to cover in that same span. The 49.5-point total has been set for this contest, particularly striking given Buffalo's offensive firepower and the over connecting in four of the previous five encounters between these division rivals.

Patriots vs Bills Odds Movement & Analysis

The moneyline market mirrors this sentiment with pronounced movement:

• Buffalo Bills Moneyline: Climbed from -380 to -450
• New England Patriots Moneyline: Extended from +300 to +350

The most intriguing aspect involves the total, which opened at 49.5 points and has remained completely static despite historical trends favoring higher-scoring affairs. The immovable line suggests oddsmakers possess strong conviction that this contest will develop into a defensive struggle, directly contradicting recent head-to-head history where offensive fireworks have been the norm.

Betting Strategy: The line movement has created distinct opportunities for sharp bettors. Patriots backers have benefited from patience, now receiving as much as +8 on the spread. Given New England's perfect 4-0 ATS record in recent meetings with Buffalo, this additional value proves significant. The frozen total presents the biggest market puzzle, defying both teams' recent offensive success and suggesting the oddsmakers' projection of a methodical, possession-limited game represents strong professional conviction.

Patriots vs Bills Injury Report

Both teams enter this crucial divisional clash managing extensive injury concerns, with 18 total players appearing on the combined report. The defensive units bear the brunt of these ailments, potentially transforming a game projected for historically low scoring.

New England Patriots

The Patriots' defensive depth faces its biggest test with linebacker K'Lavon Chaisson sidelined by a knee injury after missing practice entirely. This absence significantly weakens New England's pass rush capabilities against Buffalo's potent aerial attack. However, Christian Gonzalez made his season debut for New England last week, and will likely be a bit more up to speed for the Sunday night clash vs the Bills.

Buffalo Bills

Buffalo confronts more pressing defensive concerns with multiple starters compromised. Linebacker Matt Milano and defensive lineman Ed Oliver were both limited in practice throughout the week, making their availability highly questionable for Sunday night.

Patriots vs Bills – Key Matchups to Watch

The outcome of this AFC East battle will likely hinge on several critical confrontations, with both teams' injury-depleted defenses creating exploitable advantages for the opposing offenses.

Patriots Ground Attack vs Bills Front Seven

New England's offensive identity revolves around methodical ball control, featuring the dynamic duo of Rhamondre Stevenson and Antonio Gibson. Their mission involves controlling possession—they average 30:29 per game—while keeping Buffalo's explosive offense sidelined. The Patriots face a Bills run defense severely compromised by injuries to linebacker Matt Milano and defensive tackle Ed Oliver, both limited by significant ailments. More critically, starting linebacker Dorian Williams appears unlikely to suit up after missing practice entirely.

If New England's offensive line can exploit these defensive vulnerabilities, they possess the personnel to establish sustained drives and dictate game tempo. With both teams converting red zone opportunities at identical 66.7% rates, the Patriots' ability to consistently reach scoring territory through ground-based attack could prove decisive.

Stefon Diggs Return vs Bills Secondary

The emotional centerpiece of this contest features Stefon Diggs facing his former teammates for the first time since his trade to New England. Diggs teams with reliable targets Hunter Henry and Austin Hooper to challenge a Buffalo secondary potentially missing starting cornerback Dorian Strong.

The Patriots' passing attack emphasizes efficiency over volume, reflected in their superior +3 turnover differential. Offensive coordinator will likely scheme specific opportunities to isolate Diggs against Buffalo's compromised coverage, creating potential for explosive plays in a revenge-game scenario that has captivated the football world.

Bills Aerial Circus vs Patriots Coverage

Buffalo's offensive juggernaut has dismantled opponents through four games, with the versatile attack controlling possession for 34:04 per contest while maintaining a commanding +8:09 time of possession advantage. Their success originates from exceptional offensive line play that provides clean pockets and creates rushing lanes.

However, they face a New England defense missing key pass rusher K'Lavon Chaisson, placing enormous pressure on Harold Landry III and Christian Barmore to generate consistent pressure. If they cannot disrupt Buffalo's timing, the Bills possess the firepower to exploit even the most talented secondaries.

Patriots Protection vs Bills Pass Rush

While Buffalo's defense battles injuries, their pass rush maintains potency with Joey Bosa appearing healthy after full practice participation. The critical question mark surrounds Ed Oliver's ankle injury, which could diminish his trademark explosiveness from the interior.

New England's offensive line faces the crucial task of protecting their quarterback and allowing their methodical offense to function effectively. The Patriots' discipline has been questioned this season. If Bosa can consistently win his matchups and force holding calls or obvious passing situations, it could derail New England's ball-control philosophy and play directly into Buffalo's strengths.

Patriots vs Bills Passing Props

The quarterback prop market reflects the exceptionally low game total while presenting intriguing statistical projections that deserve careful analysis from sharp bettors.

The most striking element involves Maye carrying a higher passing yardage prop (228.5) than superstar Josh Allen (224.5). This anomaly could reflect anticipated negative game script for the Patriots or an opportunity to attack Buffalo's compromised secondary. However, the line appears aggressive for a quarterback leading an offense averaging just 336.2 total yards per game.

The market demonstrates heavy skepticism regarding Maye's touchdown production, pricing the under 1.5 passing scores at steep -170 juice while expecting him to commit a turnover with the over 0.5 interceptions favored at -113.

For Allen, oddsmakers project hyper-efficiency over volume production. His 224.5 passing yards line seems conservative for a quarterback whose team averages 404 yards per game, yet the market heavily favors touchdown production with over 1.5 passing scores priced at -164. Despite Buffalo's troublesome -3 turnover differential, Allen receives significant respect for ball security, with under 0.5 interceptions commanding -165 juice.

Patriots vs Bills Rushing & Receiving Props

The player prop landscape reflects both the historically low game total and each team's distinct offensive identity, creating several angles that sharp bettors should consider.

NFL player props as of October 4, 2025 from DraftKings.

Analysis & Key Betting Angles:

Bills running back James Cook carries substantial expectations with his 74.5 rushing yards prop, suggesting oddsmakers anticipate him exploiting a Patriots defense potentially missing linebacker K'Lavon Chaisson. However, the props for Patriots backs Rhamondre Stevenson (31.5) appear surprisingly conservative, potentially undervaluing New England's ground-based approach against Buffalo's injury-riddled front seven.

Stefon Diggs faces a modest 48.5 receiving yards line in his emotional return to Buffalo, a number that seems to reflect the Patriots' methodical offensive approach rather than his individual talent level. This creates potential value for bettors expecting the revenge-game narrative to manifest in increased target share and aggressive route concepts.

Among Buffalo receivers, Khalil Shakir (44.5 yards) emerges as the primary aerial threat over rookie Keon Coleman (38.5). However, Coleman's superior anytime touchdown odds (+175) suggest red zone usage could favor the young receiver's size and athleticism.

Two players command attention for touchdown production. James Cook stands as the overwhelming favorite to reach the end zone at -220, indicating the market expects Buffalo to lean heavily on their ground game in scoring situations. Close behind sits Josh Allen himself, whose dual-threat ability earns anytime touchdown odds of -130 alongside a 29.5 rushing yards prop that reflects his mobility.

For New England, tight end Hunter Henry presents intriguing value with his receptions prop set at 3.5 with heavy juice favoring the over (-159). This signals expected heavy volume against a Buffalo linebacker corps potentially missing multiple starters.

Patriots vs Bills Picks & Prediction

This Sunday Night Football showcase presents a compelling study in contrasting philosophies, with Buffalo's aerial dominance facing New England's methodical ground attack in a game where defensive injuries could prove decisive. While the Bills enter undefeated and command home-field advantage, their path to covering the 8-point spread faces significant obstacles, primarily their compromised defensive personnel.

The Patriots' game plan will target Buffalo's depleted front seven, missing linebacker Dorian Williams entirely while featuring limited versions of Matt Milano and star defensive tackle Ed Oliver. By establishing their ground game behind Rhamondre Stevenson and controlling possession—they average 30:29 per game—New England can limit exposure for Buffalo's explosive offense that has averaged 404 yards per contest.

The quarterback matchup favors Josh Allen's superior talent and experience, yet he faces a New England defense that has excelled in creating turnovers with their +3 differential. However, the Patriots' pass rush suffers significantly without K'Lavon Chaisson, potentially providing Allen the clean pockets necessary to operate Buffalo's high-octane attack. Conversely, Drake Maye confronts a Buffalo pass rush still featuring Joey Bosa, though Ed Oliver's ankle concerns could limit interior pressure.

The emotional subplot surrounding Stefon Diggs' return adds another layer of intrigue, with the veteran receiver potentially motivated for a signature performance against his former teammates. His familiarity with Buffalo's defensive schemes, combined with the Bills' secondary potentially missing Dorian Strong, creates opportunities for explosive plays that could keep New England within striking distance.

Ultimately, the defensive injuries plaguing Buffalo prove too significant to overlook, particularly for a team asked to cover a substantial divisional spread. New England possesses the exact offensive identity—methodical, ball-control approach—necessary to exploit these specific vulnerabilities while keeping the game within reach.

Fearless Forecast - Against the Spread (ATS): New England Patriots +8 (-110)
The Patriots have dominated this rivalry from a betting perspective, going 4-0 ATS in their last four meetings with Buffalo. With the Bills' defense severely compromised by injuries to Milano, Oliver, Williams, and Strong, New England's ground-heavy attack is perfectly positioned to control tempo and keep this divisional battle close. We'll gladly take the points.

Lock of the Week - Over/Under: Over 49.5 (-110)
This total defies all logical analysis and recent trends. The over has connected in all three of Buffalo's home games this season and four of the last five head-to-head meetings. With significant defensive injuries impacting both units, both offenses should find more success than this historically low number suggests. The sharp money agrees—this feels like a classic oddsmaker trap.

Use the linked DraftKings promo code to score an offer to bet $5 and get $200 in bonus bets (if you win).

Best Player Props:

• Hunter Henry Over 3.5 Receptions (-159): Buffalo's most vulnerable area sits over the middle with their top linebackers either sidelined or limited. Henry serves as Maye's security blanket, and the market is telegraphing heavy volume.
• Rhamondre Stevenson Over 31.5 Rushing Yards (-115): This line disrespects a lead back whose team's entire identity revolves around establishing the ground game against an injury-depleted run defense.

Upset Special - Same Game Parlay (+350):

• Patriots +13.5 (Alternate Spread)
• Over 49.5 Total Points
• Hunter Henry 25+ Receiving Yards

Public Betting Splits

The betting public and professional money have reached consensus on the outright winner but are engaged in a fierce battle over the total, creating one of the week's most fascinating market dynamics.

Market Analysis:

The moneyline market shows remarkable unanimity, with 97.35% of tickets and 98.06% of handle backing Buffalo for the outright victory. This overwhelming consensus reflects confidence in the undefeated Bills maintaining perfection at home.

The spread presents more intrigue, with recreational bettors slightly favoring the Patriots and the points while sharp money leans toward Buffalo -8.

The total creates the week's most compelling "sharps versus public" scenario. While 59.8% of all bets target the Under 49.5, an overwhelming 70.94% of the money backs the Over. This massive discrepancy indicates professional bettors believe oddsmakers have created significant value with the historically low number, strongly validating our Over selection.

Recent History: Patriots vs Bills

The recent history between these AFC East rivals reveals a fascinating contradiction between game outcomes and betting performance that should influence Sunday night's approach. While Buffalo has established divisional dominance over the past several seasons, their meetings with New England have consistently been more competitive than final standings suggest.

The betting trends paint a clear picture of value:

• New England is 4-0 against the spread in their last four encounters with Buffalo
• The Over has connected in four of the last five head-to-head battles

These patterns become even more significant when considering the current injury landscape. Buffalo's defense, typically a strength in previous meetings, enters this contest severely compromised with key contributors either sidelined or limited. Conversely, the Patriots will test their defensive depth without pass rusher K'Lavon Chaisson. While history suggests a competitive, high-scoring affair, these new defensive variables add unpredictability that could fundamentally alter the game's trajectory compared to recent encounters where both units were closer to full strength.