Madden 23 rookie ratings: Here are the best rookies for 2022, from Sauce Gardner to Jameson Williams

Zac Al-Khateeb

Madden 23 rookie ratings: Here are the best rookies for 2022, from Sauce Gardner to Jameson Williams image

The full list of Madden 23 player ratings is out, and in addition to the established stars, people always want to know how NFL newcomers will fare. A total of 55 rookies rated in the 70s in the latest edition of the NFL video game franchise; none rated in the 80s.

The three top-rated rookies in Madden 23 are Jets corner Sauce Gardner, Lions receiver Jameson Williams and Eagles defensive tackle Jordan Davis — the Nos. 4, 12 and 13 picks of the 2022 NFL Draft, respectively — all given a 78 overall rating. No. 1 overall pick Travon Walker is tied for the seventh-highest rating among rookies (with six other players), at 76. Aidan Hutchinson, the No. 2 overall pick, is tied for third with a 77 rating.

As for who had the best rookies — per Madden ratings, anyway — that distinction belongs to the Jets, with three of the top 13 newcomers. The Lions have two of the top six while the Giants have two in the top 20.

MORE: Madden ratings tracker — Complete list of best players in each position group

With that, The Sporting News presents a breakdown of the top-rated rookies in Madden 23, including a position-by-position look at the NFL's first-year players.

Let the debates (and arguments) begin:

Madden 23 top rookie ratings

A total of 20 rookies — 10 offensive players, 10 defensive — rated at 75 or better in the Madden 23 rankings. Those include six players at 75; seven at 76; four at 77; and three at 78.

The most-represented positions atop the board are receiver (five), followed by cornerback, outside linebacker, running back and safety (three players apiece). This list includes no quarterbacks.

Here's the list of every rookie rated 75 or better:

RatingPlayerPositionTeam
78Jameson WilliamsWRDetroit Lions
78Jordan DavisDTPhiladelphia Eagles
78Sauce GardnerCBNew York Jets
77Aidan HutchinsonLOLBDetroit Lions
77Derek StingleyCBHouston Texans
77Evan NealRTNew York Giants
77Kenneth WalkerRBSeattle Seahawks
76Breece HallRBNew York Jets
76Chris OlaveWRNew Orleans Saints
76Garrett WilsonWRNew York Jets
76Ikem EkwonuLTCarolina Panthers
76Kyle HamiltonSSBaltimore Ravens
76Travon WalkerLOLBJacksonville Jaguars
76Trent McDuffieCBKansas City Chiefs
75Daxton HillFSCincinnati Bengals
75Drake LondonWRAtlanta Falcons
75Jahan DotsonWRWashington Commanders
75James CookRBBuffalo Bills
75Kayvon ThibodeauxROLBNew York Giants
75Lewis CineFSMinnesota Vikings

Madden 23 rookie positional ratings

MORE: Madden 23 QB ratings, from Tom Brady to Patrick Mahome

Quarterback

RatingPlayerTeam
70Desmond RidderAtlanta Falcons
69Malik WillisTennessee Titans
68Kenny PickettPittsburgh Steelers
68Matt CorralCarolina Panthers
67Sam HowellWashington Commanders

MORE: Madden 23 WR ratings, from Davante Adams to Tyreek Hill

Wide Receiver

RatingPlayerTeam
78Jameson WilliamsDetroit Lions
76Chris OlaveNew Orleans Saints
76Garrett WilsonNew York Jets
75Drake LondonAtlanta Falcons
75Jahan DotsonWashington Commanders

MORE: Madden 23 RB ratings, from Derrick Henry to Ezekiel Elliott

Running back

RatingPlayerTeam
77Kenneth WalkerSeattle Seahawks
76Breece HallNew York Jets
75James CookBuffalo Bills
73Isaiah SpillerLos Angeles Chargers
72Brian RobinsonWashington Commanders
72Dameon PierceHouston Texans

Tight End

RatingPlayerTeam
73Trey McBrideArizona Cardinals
70Greg DucichDenver Broncos
69Jelani WoodsIndianapolis Colts
68Jeremy RuckertNew York Jets
67Cade OttonTampa Bay Buccaneers
67Charlie KolarBaltimore Ravens

Left Tackle

RatingPlayerTeam
76Ikem EkwonuCarolina Panthers
73Charles CrossSeattle Seahawks
72Trevor PenningNew Orleans Saints
68Bernhard RaimannIndianapolis Colts
66Max MitchellNew York Jets

Right Tackle

RatingPlayerTeam
77Evan NealNew York Giants
67Daniel FaaleleBaltimore Ravens
67Zach TomGreen Bay Packers
66Nicholas Petit-FrereTennessee Titans
66Abraham LucasSeattle Seahawks

Left Guards

RatingPlayerTeam
72Kenyon GreenHouston Texans
70Tyler SmithDallas Cowboys
69Sean RhyanGreen Bay Packers
68Cam JurgensPhiladelphia Eagles
68Luke GoedekeTampa Bay Buccaneers

Right Guard

RatingPlayerTeam
73Zion JohnsonLos Angeles Chargers
70Cole StrangeNew England Patriots
69Ed IngramMinnesota Vikings
67Dylan ParhamLos Vegas Raiders
65Darian KinnardKansas City Chiefs
65Logan BrussLos Angeles Rams
65Marcus McKethanNew York Giants

Center

RatingPlayerTeam
74Tyler LinderbaumBaltimore Ravens
65Luke FortnerJacksonville Jaguars
63Luke WattenbergDenver Broncos
63Doug KramerChicago Bears

MORE: Madden 23 EDGE ratings, from Myles Garrett to Von Miller

Left End

RatingPlayerTeam
74George KarlaftisKansas City Chiefs
74Jermaine JohnsonNew York Jets
68DeMarvin LealPittsburgh Steelers
65Matt HenningsenDenver Broncos
64Isaiah ThomasCleveland Browns

Right End

RatingPlayerTeam
73Devonte WyattGreen Bay Packers
70Logan HallTampa Bay Buccaneers
69Drake JacksonSan Francisco 49ers
68Sam WilliamsDallas Cowboys
66Myjai SandersArizona Cardinals

Defensive Tackle

RatingPlayerTeam
78Jordan DavisPhiladelphia Eagles
71Phidarian MathisWashington Commanders
70Travis JonesBaltimore Ravens
67Eyioma UwazurikeDenver Broncos
67Perrion WinfreyCleveland Browns

Left Outside Linebacker

RatingPlayerTeam
77Aidan HutchinsonDetroit Lions
76Travon WalkerJacksonville Jaguars
72Arnold EbiketieAtlanta Falcons
71David OjaboBaltimore Ravens
69Josh PaschalDetroit Lions
69Nik BonnitoDenver Broncos

Right Outside Linebacker

RatingPlayerTeam
75Kayvon ThibodeauxNew York Giants
68Boye MafeSeattle Seahawks
67DeAngelo MaloneAtlanta Falcons
66Brandon SmithCarolina Panthers
65D'Marco JacksonNew Orleans Saints

Middle Linebacker

RatingPlayerTeam
73Devin LloydJacksonville Jaguars
73Quay WalkerGreen Bay Packers
71Nakobe DeanPhiladelphia Eagles
70Chad MumaJacksonville Jaguars
69Leo ChenalKansas City Chiefs
69Troy AndersenAtlanta Falcons

MORE: Madden 23 CB ratings, from Jalen Ramsey to Kenny Moore II

Cornerback

RatingPlayerTeam
78Sauce GardnerNew York Jets
77Derek StingleyHouston Texans
76Trent McDuffieKansas City Chiefs
73Andrew BoothMinnesota Vikings
73Kaiir ElamBuffalo Bills

Free Safety

RatingPlayerTeam
75Daxton HillCincinnati Bengals
75Lewis CineMinnesota Vikings
73Jalen PitreHouston Texans
68JT WoodsLos Angeles Chargers
67Kerby JosephDetroit Lions

Strong Safety

RatingPlayerTeam
76Kyle HamiltonBaltimore Ravens
73Jaquan BriskerChicago Bears
70Bryan CookKansas City Chiefs
66Dane BeltonNew York Giants
69Nick CrossIndianapolis Colts

Kicker

RatingPlayerTeam
73Cade YorkCleveland Browns

Punter

RatingPlayerTeam
74Matt AraizaBuffalo Bills
73Jordan StoutBaltimore Ravens
73Jake CamardaTampa Bay Buccaneers
69Trenton GillChicago Bears

Zac Al-Khateeb

Zac Al-Khateeb has been part of The Sporting News team since 2015 after earning his Bachelor's (2013) and Master's (2014) degrees in journalism at the University of Alabama. Prior to joining TSN, he covered high school sports and general news in Alabama. A college sports specialist, Zac has been a voter for the Biletnikoff Award and Heisman Trophy since 2020.