2018 Fantasy Baseball Rankings: Starting Pitcher

Matt Lutovsky

2018 Fantasy Baseball Rankings: Starting Pitcher image

Where does a fantasy baseball owner even begin with starting pitcher rankings? Well, that's actually easy -- you begin with Clayton Kershaw -- but, in general, putting together SP rankings for your draft cheat sheet is as difficult as anything you'll do all season. Strikeouts are the most consistent statistic from year-to-year, so often sleepers and busts are based on Ks. But we all know that a little batted-ball or run-support luck can go a long way in helping a starter's fantasy value in any given season, turning the No. 60 pre-draft pitcher into a top-20 commodity by the end of the year.

In addition to the "luck factor" that advanced statheads love to talk about, you also have the injury factor. No pitcher is safe, and an "injury risk" with depressed value can just as easily have a healthy, breakout season as a "safe pitcher" can experience his first DL stint. 

This year, we have a few new variables -- a rookie pitcher who's also planning to be a semi-regular hitter (Shohei Ohtani); a new humidor in one of the most hitter-friendly parks in the league (Chase Field in Arizona)-- that are sure to make things even more complicated. 

MORE FANTASY BASEBALL: 2018 draft cheat sheet

As with any set of rankings, age, injury history, consistency, and advanced stats all carry a lot of weight, but when things get rolling in your draft, you can bet some people will place more trust in recent performance (i.e. last year) and/or age (i.e. veterans are all declining; youngsters are all improving), and overdraft/overlook certain players. We try to balance things out in our rankings, but we know this won't be the order in which these guys are drafted -- and it certainly won't be the order in which they finish.

Drafting pitching really comes down to one thing: The amount of risk with which you're comfortable. Of course, virtually any draft strategy is a risk. Drafting two bonafide aces early is riskier than drafting two stud hitters, but not drafting any "safe" pitchers can really put you behind early, even if you plan to be active on the waiver wire. Even a "balanced approach" can backfire depending on the players you take, but at least you give yourself outs.

If you dig into the advanced numbers and fall back on Ks when all else fails, you can put together a good rotation on draft day. Once the season starts, if you play the matchups with your back-end SPs, you can have even more success. Outside of the top 25 or 30 guys (and even some of them if they're in Coors Field or Yankee Stadium), any pitcher can be benched. Remember that before overdrafting a mediocre starter just because he's the last player in a certain tier.

2018 FANTASY BASEBALL RANKINGS:
Catcher | FirstSecond | Third | Shortstop | OutfieldReliever

2018 Fantasy Baseball Rankings: Starting Pitcher

Rankings based on Wins/Ks/ERA/WHIP. Eligibility based on Yahoo's default settings.

RankPlayerTeam
1Clayton KershawDodgers
2Max ScherzerNationals
3Corey KluberIndians
4Chris SaleRed Sox
5Noah SyndergaardMets
6Stephen StrasburgNationals
7Carlos CarrascoIndians
8Jacob deGromMets
9Luis SeverinoYankees
10Zack GreinkeDiamondbacks
11Justin VerlanderAstros
12Robbie RayDiamondbacks
13Yu DarvishCubs
14Chris ArcherRays
15Carlos MartinezCardinals
16Aaron NolaPhillies
17James PaxtonMariners
18Dallas KeuchelAstros
19Alex WoodDodgers
20David PriceRed Sox
21Zack GodleyDiamondbacks
22Lance McCullers Jr.Astros
23Jose QuintanaCubs
24Kyle HendricksCubs
25Jose BerriosTwins
26Luis CastilloReds
27Jon LesterCubs
28Jake ArrietaPhillies
29Rich HillDodgers
30Shohei OhtaniAngels
31Masahiro TanakaYankees
32Gerrit ColeAstros
33Johnny CuetoGiants
34Sonny GrayYankees
35Jameson TaillonPirates
36Danny DuffyRoyals
37Garrett RichardsAngels
38Luke WeaverCardinals
39Kenta MaedaDodgers
40Jon GrayRockies
41Charlie MortonAstros
42Madison BumgarnerGiants
43Danny SalazarIndians
44Cole HamelsRangers
45Jeff SamardzijaGiants
46Drew PomeranzRed Sox
47Gio GonzalezNationals
48Chase AndersonBrewers
49Sean ManaeaA's
50Trevor BauerIndians
51Michael FulmerTigers
52Jake FariaRays
53Dylan BundyOrioles
54Jordan MontgomeryYankees
55Felix HernandezMariners
56Michael WachaCardinals
57Brandon McCarthyBraves
58Mike ClevingerIndians
59Marcus StromanBlue Jays
60Aaron SanchezBlue Jays
61Alex CobbOrioles
62Lucas GiolitoWhite Sox
63Eduardo RodriguezRed Sox
64Blake SnellRays
65Julio TeheranBraves
66Alex ReyesCardinals
67Ervin SantanaTwins
68Luiz GoharaBraves
69Marco EstradaBlue Jays
70Taijuan WalkerDiamondbacks
71Tanner RoarkNationals
72Lance LynnTwins
73Dinelson LametPadres
74Andrew HeaneyAngels
75J.A. HappBlue Jays
76Tyler ChatwoodCubs
77Kevin GausmanOrioles
78Rick PorcelloRed Sox
79Nick PivettaPhillies
80Dan StrailyMarlins
81Sean NewcombBraves
82Carlos RodonWhite Sox
83Tyler GlasnowPirates
84Zach DaviesBrewers
85Jake OdorizziTwins
86Mike LeakeMariners
87Jerad EickhoffPhillies
88Adam WainwrightCardinals
89Anthony DeSclafaniReds
90Hyun-jin RyuDodgers
91Mike MinorRangers
92Miles MikolasCardinals
93Patrick CorbinDiamondbacks
94CC SabathiaYankees
95Matt ShoemakerAngels
96Jimmy NelsonBrewers
97Julio UriasDodgers
98Michael FolynewiczBraves
99Doug FisterRangers
100Joe MusgrovePirates
101Ivan NovaPirates
102Michael KopechWhite Sox
103Tyler AndersonRockies
104Tyler SkaggsAngels
105Steven MatzMets
106German MarquezRockies
107Jharel CottonA's
108Matt HarveyMets

Matt Lutovsky

Matt Lutovsky has been a writer and editor for The Sporting News since 2007, primarily writing about fantasy sports, betting, and gaming.